In the ever-evolving world of beauty products, finding that perfect concealer can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. Today, I’m reviewing the Maybelline New York Dream Brightening Creamy Concealer in Fair (0.11 oz), a product that has garnered quite a following among makeup enthusiasts of all experience levels. As a beauty expert who has seen countless concealers come and go, I was particularly interested in examining why this affordable drugstore option continues to maintain its popularity despite the flood of high-end alternatives in the market.
First Impressions and Packaging
The Maybelline Dream Brightening Concealer comes in a lipstick-style tube that’s both practical and portable. The slim design makes it easy to toss into your makeup bag, purse, or even pocket for on-the-go touch-ups. Several users mentioned keeping multiple tubes in different locations—purse, car, and home—highlighting its convenience factor. The twist-up mechanism eliminates the need for sharpening, which means less product waste and cleaner application.
At first glance, the packaging appears sturdy enough to withstand being “tossed around” in bags, as one reviewer specifically mentioned. The cap stays securely in place, preventing the product from drying out prematurely—something that many users appreciated about the product’s longevity. One reviewer even mentioned having a stick last over a year with regular use.
Texture and Formula
The Maybelline Dream Brightening Concealer boasts a creamy yet solid texture that strikes a balance between ease of application and staying power. While some stick concealers can feel dry or drag against the skin, numerous reviewers praised this product for going on smoothly without pulling at the delicate under-eye area.
The formula is described as “creamy,” “smooth,” and having “good quality texture” and “thickness.” It’s worth noting that there were a few contradicting opinions about the consistency—while most found it creamy and easy to blend, a small minority of reviewers described it as “thick and chalky” or “very dry and hard to blend.” This suggests that skin type might play a role in how the product performs, with those having drier skin potentially experiencing more difficulty with blending.
An interesting feature mentioned by several reviewers is the presence of light-reflecting particles or what some described as “teeny tiny flecks of glitter.” These particles contribute to the “brightening” aspect of the product, though opinions on this feature were divided. Some loved the illuminating effect, while others found the shimmer to be too noticeable or inappropriate for a concealer.
Coverage and Performance
The Dream Brightening Concealer offers what most describe as medium coverage. It’s effective enough to cover dark circles, blemishes, and minor discolorations without looking heavy or cakey. This makes it particularly suitable for those seeking a natural “no makeup” look or for minimal makeup days.
The product seems to excel particularly at brightening the under-eye area, with many reviewers specifically mentioning its effectiveness at combating “raccoon eyes” and “zombie-like pale skin.” Its brightening properties make it double as a highlighter, with several users mentioning they apply it to the inner corners of their eyes or beneath their eyebrows for added dimension.
Longevity appears to be good but not exceptional. Most reviewers reported that it lasts throughout a standard workday, especially when set with powder. One reviewer specifically mentioned it lasting about 8 hours. The concealer also received positive marks for not melting off in hot weather, which is a notable advantage for a product at this price point.
Several reviewers mentioned that the product doesn’t settle into fine lines as much as other concealers they’ve tried, though this wasn’t a universal experience. A few users in their late 30s or older noted that it did accentuate fine lines under their eyes, suggesting that skin texture and age might influence how the product performs in this regard.
Application Tips
Based on reviewer feedback, the Dream Brightening Concealer performs best when applied and blended properly. Here are some application tips gleaned from the reviews:
- Direct application and blending: Many users prefer drawing the product directly onto the skin and then blending it out with either fingers or a brush. The stick format makes precise application easier than liquid or pot concealers.
- Layering: Several reviewers mentioned that the coverage is buildable, allowing you to transition from sheer to full coverage without caking or smearing.
- Setting with powder: To extend wear time and prevent creasing, setting the concealer with a light dusting of loose powder was a common recommendation.
- Using as a multi-purpose product: Beyond concealing, many users repurpose this product as a highlighter for the browbone, inner corner of the eyes, or as an eyeshadow base/primer.
- Application method warning: One reviewer cautioned against applying the product directly from the tube, suggesting that it might stretch the skin and potentially increase wrinkles. Instead, they recommended applying with fingers.
Color Range and Matching
The “Fair” shade of the Dream Brightening Concealer seems to work well for those with very light skin tones, with one “natural redhead with stereotypical zombie-like pale skin” finding it “absolutely perfect.” However, the shade range appears to be limited, and there were a few complaints about color matching, with one reviewer receiving a product marked “Fair” that was “way off” in color.
Several reviewers mentioned that the Fair shade has pink undertones, making it particularly suitable for those with cool undertones. For those with very fair skin who struggle to find light enough concealers, this product seems to be a good option, especially during winter months when skin tends to be paler.
Value for Money
At its price point (which several reviewers noted has increased over the years but still remains affordable), the Maybelline Dream Brightening Concealer offers exceptional value. Multiple reviewers compared it favorably to high-end alternatives, with one specifically mentioning that they switched back to MAC concealer, which was “crazy expensive and harder to use” but didn’t have the glittery effect.
The product’s longevity adds to its value proposition, with many users reporting that a single stick lasts for months or even over a year with regular use. The fact that the formula doesn’t dry out quickly (when properly capped) further enhances its cost-effectiveness.
Special Considerations
Skin Sensitivity
A few reviewers reported experiencing burning or irritation when applying the product near their eyes. While this was not a widespread complaint, those with sensitive skin or eyes might want to patch test before full application.
Discontinued Concerns
Several reviewers mentioned concerns that this product might be discontinued, with one specifically noting that “Maybelline announced it is discontinued.” This could explain why some found it increasingly difficult to locate in physical stores and turned to online purchasing.
Skin Types
The concealer seems to work well across different skin types, with one reviewer specifically mentioning that “this formula works good for my oily skin.” However, those with very dry under-eyes might experience some issues with blending and potential creasing.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Affordable price point
- Convenient stick format for precise application
- Brightening effect that works well for under-eye circles
- Smooth application without pulling the skin
- Long-lasting formula that doesn’t dry out quickly
- Portable and travel-friendly packaging
- Works well as both a concealer and highlighter
- Buildable coverage
- Generally doesn’t melt off in hot weather
- Paraben-free formula (mentioned by one reviewer)
Cons:
- Light-reflecting particles may be too noticeable for some
- Limited shade range
- May settle into fine lines, especially for mature skin
- Some reports of skin irritation
- Not universally easy to blend
- Coverage may be too sheer for those seeking full coverage
- Possible discontinuation by the manufacturer
Who Should Buy This Product?
The Maybelline New York Dream Brightening Creamy Concealer would be ideal for:
- Makeup beginners looking for an easy-to-use, forgiving concealer
- Those on a budget who want quality without breaking the bank
- People with fair skin who struggle to find light enough concealers
- Minimalists seeking a natural, “no makeup” look
- Busy individuals who need quick, on-the-go touch-ups
- Those with mild to moderate dark circles or blemishes requiring medium coverage
- Anyone who prefers a brightening effect rather than just coverage
- Travelers who appreciate compact, non-liquid makeup options
Who Should Consider Alternatives?
This concealer might not be the best choice for:
- Those with very sensitive skin or eyes
- People seeking full, heavy-duty coverage
- Individuals with mature skin or pronounced fine lines
- Those who prefer a completely matte finish without any luminosity
- People with deeper skin tones given the limited shade range
Final Verdict
The Maybelline New York Dream Brightening Creamy Concealer in Fair stands as a testament to the fact that effective makeup doesn’t need to come with a luxury price tag. Its creamy formula, convenient packaging, and brightening properties make it a worthy addition to any makeup collection, particularly for those seeking a natural-looking concealer with added luminosity.
While it may not be perfect for everyone—particularly those with very mature skin, sensitivity issues, or needs for full coverage—its versatility, ease of use, and affordable price point make it a low-risk investment with potentially high returns in your beauty routine.
With the possibility of discontinuation looming, loyal users might want to stock up while it’s still available. For those who haven’t tried it yet, it represents an excellent entry point into the world of stick concealers without the commitment of a high-end purchase.
Overall Rating: 4.2/5 stars
This review is based on a comprehensive analysis of user feedback for the Maybelline New York Dream Brightening Creamy Concealer in Fair (0.11 oz).
Buy on Amazon: Here
