When it comes to eyeliner, the market is vast and saturated. Every brand promises long wear, precision, comfort, and pigmentation. But as any makeup artist or beauty enthusiast will tell you, not all eyeliners are created equal. The Maybelline New York Define-A-Line Eyeliner in Brownish Black has quietly maintained a loyal following for years—and for good reason. In this in-depth review, I’ll unpack the formula, performance, versatility, and user experience of this product through both expert testing and real user feedback. The aim is to go far beyond surface-level impressions and help you determine whether this eyeliner deserves a place in your makeup bag.
First Impressions: Simple, Sleek, and Effective
The Define-A-Line eyeliner isn’t flashy. It comes in a no-nonsense plastic casing with a twist-up mechanism—no sharpening necessary. This alone is a huge selling point for many, especially those who, like me, have spent more time than we’d care to admit digging through drawers for a compatible sharpener. The color I’m reviewing here is Brownish Black, a surprisingly nuanced shade that sits beautifully between warm brown and soft black. It’s an ideal tone for those seeking definition without the harshness of jet black.
The pencil features a built-in smudger sponge at the opposite end of the liner. It’s a small addition, but one that can significantly expand the product’s functionality. A hidden sharpener is also included in the cap—a thoughtful touch, though many users, myself included, find they rarely need it due to the liner’s naturally fine point and creamy formula.
Texture and Application: Creamy Glide with Zero Tug
What sets this eyeliner apart from many in its category is the texture. The formula is soft and creamy, gliding across the skin with ease. There’s no need to press hard or go over the same spot multiple times—one stroke delivers rich, even pigment. For people with sensitive or mature eyelids, this is a game-changer. The last thing you want is a stiff, dry pencil that tugs on delicate skin. And for those of us who remember the 90s, when we used to warm up our pencils with a lighter to make them usable, this pencil is a modern miracle.
Numerous users have praised this product for how well it applies—even on crepey or aging lids. One reviewer noted that it didn’t skip during application, a common issue with other liners, especially on textured skin. The twist-up design ensures that you always have a ready tip, and the pigment payoff is strong enough that you don’t need to layer excessively.
Wearability: A Double-Edged Sword?
Let’s get into the core of what everyone wants to know: does it stay put?
Here’s where the story gets nuanced. The Define-A-Line eyeliner wears well if you use it with intention. It’s not a 24-hour, budge-proof warrior—but it isn’t meant to be. The formula is designed to be blendable, ideal for soft smoky looks or subtle definition. That blendability naturally comes at the expense of transfer-resistance. On oily lids or in humid environments, it may smudge or migrate, especially if applied heavily or without primer.
Some users report that it bleeds onto the upper eyelid over time, particularly for those with deep-set or hooded eyes. Others have found it to last the entire day without issues. A key factor here seems to be application technique and personal habits. If you’re someone who touches your eyes often, or if your lids are particularly oily, this eyeliner may transfer. On the flip side, if you’ve trained yourself to avoid contact with your makeup and you prep your lids well, it can hold its own through a full day.
Versatility: More Than Just an Eyeliner
One of the more fascinating things about this product is its unexpected versatility. While it’s marketed as an eyeliner, several users have shared that they use it as a lip liner, eyebrow pencil, or even as a base for lipstick blending. As a makeup professional, I’m always intrigued by products that transcend their initial purpose, and this one absolutely qualifies.
The shade “Brownish Black” is subtle enough to fill in brows without looking cartoonish and warm enough to use around the lips for creating definition or contour. One reviewer noted that they blend their lipstick into this liner for a more customized look, and it works! While it might not be an obvious choice for lip or brow use, its soft formula makes it surprisingly suitable for these alternative applications.
This is a classic case of a product being elevated by creative user adaptation—a reminder that great makeup is often as much about how you use it as what it is.
Color Payoff: Don’t Judge the Pencil by Its Cover
If there’s one consistent piece of advice echoed by users, it’s this: don’t let the pencil’s outward appearance fool you. The “Brownish Black” shade may look overly brown in the stick, but once applied to the skin, it deepens and settles into a rich, dimensional tone that’s flattering on most complexions. It’s a go-to for people with blue eyes, as it enhances the eye color without overwhelming it. The pigment also complements green and hazel eyes beautifully, adding definition without veering into harsh territory.
That being said, if you’re someone who prefers crisp, graphic lines or extremely bold pigment, this eyeliner may not be your best match. It’s more suited for soft glam looks, everyday wear, and those who prefer a more natural enhancement.
The Smudger and Sharpener: Hit or Miss
Let’s talk about the built-in tools. The smudger at the base is designed for blending and creating a smoky effect. In theory, it’s a convenient feature. In practice, it’s… polarizing. While some users appreciate its inclusion, others have found it ineffective or have even swapped it out with a smudger from a different product. The sponge can feel stiff and imprecise, especially compared to dedicated blending tools or even a basic Q-tip.
On the other hand, the sharpener built into the cap is a clever touch. While many people don’t use it due to the automatic twist-up design, it’s nice to have in a pinch—especially if you like a finer point for detailed work.
Sensitivity and Eye Health: A Considerate Formula
This eyeliner earns major points for its comfort. Users frequently mention that it doesn’t irritate their eyes, even when used on the waterline. That said, some have expressed concern over applying such a soft pencil in this area, especially those dealing with ocular rosacea or tear duct sensitivity. One reviewer wisely pointed out the risks of blocking tear ducts by overloading this area with creamy product. While Maybelline doesn’t market this specifically as a waterline-safe liner, the formula’s softness does make it appealing for this use—but with caveats.
I always recommend testing any product carefully around sensitive areas. While I personally didn’t experience irritation, if you’re prone to eye conditions or inflammation, proceed with caution.
Durability and Storage: A Quality Control Note
Most of the time, this eyeliner delivers consistent performance. However, there are occasional quality control issues. One reviewer shared that their eyeliner was ultra-soft and nearly liquefied upon opening, even though they lived in a cold climate. While this seems to be a rare occurrence, it’s a reminder that cosmetics can degrade or become unstable due to unseen factors—batch inconsistencies, improper storage during shipping, or even age. If your pencil arrives in poor condition, don’t hesitate to contact the seller or manufacturer for a replacement.
That said, the shelf life of this product appears generous under normal conditions. Keep it stored away from heat or direct sunlight, and you should get many months of smooth, reliable use.
Final Verdict: The Right Eyeliner for the Right User
So, is the Maybelline New York Define-A-Line Eyeliner in Brownish Black the holy grail product for everyone? No—but it comes close for a certain type of user.
If you want:
- A creamy, easy-to-apply liner that won’t tug
- A versatile pencil you can use for eyes, brows, and even lips
- A natural finish that enhances without overwhelming
- A drugstore price with department-store payoff
Then this eyeliner is absolutely worth trying.
If you need:
- Bulletproof wear through heat, humidity, or long nights
- Crisp, graphic lines that don’t blur
- A smudge-resistant or waterproof formula for oily lids
- A liner for professional photography or special occasions
Then you may want to look toward gel or liquid formulas that offer more intense longevity and control.
Expert Tips for Best Results
Here’s how I recommend using this eyeliner for maximum effect:
- Prep the eyelid: A bit of primer or translucent powder can help reduce transfer.
- Use light pressure: Let the pencil’s creaminess work for you—don’t push.
- Smudge intentionally: If you want a smoky look, use the built-in sponge or a small brush immediately after application, before the liner sets.
- Avoid waterline overuse: Be gentle on sensitive ducts and tear glands.
- Pair it with mascara: A soft liner plus volumizing mascara is a winning combo for daytime elegance.
- Store upright and cool: Prevent melting or softening by keeping it in a controlled environment.
Final Thoughts: An Oldie But a Goodie
In a world of ever-evolving beauty trends, the Maybelline Define-A-Line Eyeliner remains a reliable staple. It’s a reminder that not every product needs to be revolutionary—sometimes what we need is a dependable, versatile tool that shows up and performs day after day. This eyeliner isn’t flashy, and it’s not perfect, but it does its job—and often does it better than more expensive competitors.
For makeup lovers who prioritize comfort, blendability, and ease of use, the Define-A-Line in Brownish Black continues to hold its own. I recommend it for everyday wear, mature eyes, and anyone who appreciates the art of the soft line. Just don’t be afraid to get creative—it might surprise you with how many roles it can play.
Buy on Amazon: Here
