In the ever-evolving world of beauty products, finding that perfect mascara can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. With countless options promising everything from volume to length to curl, it’s easy to get overwhelmed. Today, I’m diving deep into Maybelline New York’s The Falsies Push Up Angel Washable Mascara in Very Black to see if this innovative product lives up to its promises of delivering angel-wing lashes without the hassle of falsies.
Maybelline’s Falsies Push Up Angel stands out immediately with its unique design. Instead of the traditional fluffy brush applicator, this mascara features a thin, curved, comb-like wand with short bristles primarily on one side. This unconventional design is intended to grip each lash from root to tip, pushing them upward and outward for that coveted wing effect.
The formula is washable (non-waterproof), making it easier to remove at the end of the day, and the color is a rich, intense black that promises to define and darken lashes for maximum impact.
The Innovative Applicator: Game-Changer or Gimmick?
The most talked-about feature of this mascara is undoubtedly its unique applicator. Unlike traditional mascara wands, the Push Up Angel features what many describe as a “comb” rather than a brush. The wand is remarkably thin and curves in a way that’s designed to push lashes upward and outward.
Initial Impressions
Upon first pulling out the wand, many users (myself included) experience a moment of doubt. The applicator looks sparse, with short bristles arranged in a row rather than the plush, full brush we’ve come to expect from mascaras. It’s natural to wonder: can something so minimal really deliver dramatic results?
Learning Curve
There is definitely a learning curve with this applicator. The design requires a slightly different application technique – it’s more about combing through the lashes rather than sweeping or wiggling. Some users found it challenging to adapt, particularly when switching between eyes, as the flared design works differently depending on which eye you’re applying to.
One reviewer noted: “A bit of a learning curve for putting this on- the flared out end works well on one eye but is hard to do on the other unless you flip your whole hand around.”
However, many users who stuck with it found that once they mastered the technique, the applicator offered unprecedented precision and control. The thin design allows you to get right to the base of the lashes and to reach even the smallest, most difficult lashes in the inner and outer corners.
Performance Review
Length and Definition
This mascara excels at lengthening and defining lashes. The comb-like design separates lashes beautifully, eliminating clumping and creating a fanned-out effect. Multiple reviewers commented on how well it works to separate individual lashes:
“This mascara makes my eyelashes longer and darker and helps to separate. I really like it. It is a natural beautiful look.”
“It separates lashes beautifully, eliminating clumping and creating a fanned-out effect.”
The lengthening effect is particularly impressive, with some users claiming dramatic results:
“If you want to end the day with super long lashes, this is the mascara for you.”
“My lashes are so short and with this mascara and a lash curler I literally have falsies now.”
Lift and Curl
True to its name, the Push Up Angel does deliver on its promise to lift lashes. Many users with straight, downward-pointing lashes found that this mascara helped them maintain curl throughout the day:
“What I most appreciated about this mascara is the lift it gives my lashes after I have curled them. Normally, my lashes point straight down, which is such a disappointment! This mascara acts as a setting lotion to hold the curl.”
Several reviewers even mentioned that they could skip their eyelash curler entirely when using this product:
“This offers great lift and definition while keeping lashes looking and feeling healthy. I love that I don’t need a lash curler anymore!”
Volume
If there’s one area where this mascara falls short for some users, it’s in providing volume. The formula seems to focus more on length and definition than on thickening:
“This is more lengthening than volumizing.”
“If you want volume and length, it only adds length. The wand does separate your lashes nicely.”
Some users compensate for this by pairing it with a more volumizing mascara:
“I use this to pull my lashes outward and then I wait a moment for it to dry a little bit and then I use another mascara with a thicker wand to finish pulling them out and making them thicker looking.”
Formula Consistency
The formula’s consistency receives mixed reviews. Some users describe it as “light and airy,” appreciating that it doesn’t feel heavy on the lashes:
“I think because it’s not waterproofed that it makes the formula so much lighter. I actually forgot I was using it.”
Others find it to be on the wetter side, which can be both a pro and a con:
“It’s a very wet formula and takes forever to dry. I have stick-straight lashes and so after I curl my lashes, this mascara takes away any curl that my lashes had.”
Several reviewers mentioned a technique of letting the wand dry out slightly before application to achieve better results.
Longevity and Wear
When it comes to staying power, reviews are mixed. Many users report that the mascara lasts well throughout the day:
“Very nice mascara. Stays put. Lasts all day.”
“No smearing or running all day. Great for a long business day without breaks.”
However, others experienced flaking or smudging issues:
“I was super excited to try this mascara & am so bummed I don’t like it. The wand is INCREDIBLE!! But it flakes so bad – to the point that I could feel it in my eye and would have to clean the pieces out with a tissue.”
“This mascara applies great and I like the way my lashes look with it. But it flakes and falls off under my eyes not long after applying it.”
The flaking issue seems to be more common when multiple coats are applied, so those going for a more dramatic look might experience more problems.
Removal Process
As a washable mascara, one of the big selling points is how easily it comes off at the end of the day. Many users praise this aspect:
“It’s easy to remove yet it stays put all day.”
“And it washes off easily with cleanser and water or any eye makeup remover.”
This easy removal makes it an excellent choice for those with sensitive eyes or those who hate struggling with stubborn waterproof formulas.
Special Benefits and Unique Uses
For Fine or Sparse Lashes
Several reviewers with fine, sparse, or aging lashes found this mascara to be particularly effective:
“I’ve been looking for a good mascara for my fine, senior citizen lashes and I’ve finally found it. Love the applicator.”
“I have very fine sparse lashes that are long and grow straight out of my lids. A lash curler and a decent mascara are my constant companions. This was a dramatically dark mascara on me. Somehow it makes it look like I have more lashes than I do.”
The precision of the applicator seems to work well for those with fewer lashes, as it can target and coat each individual lash.
For Bottom Lashes
The thin wand makes this mascara excellent for applying to bottom lashes without creating a mess:
“I have long eye lashes and I hate making a mess all over my eyes. The brush is very thin and leaves my eyes so clean.”
“The small wand also makes doing bottom lashes easy.”
Several users mentioned purchasing this mascara specifically for use on their bottom lashes, even when they prefer other products for their top lashes.
For Those with Trichotillomania
One of the most moving testimonials came from a user with trichotillomania (a hair-pulling disorder) affecting their eyelashes:
“I have Trichotillomania (hair pulling anxiety disorder) of the eyelashes. I will pull them out without even noticing and for years and years I went on thinking I could never wear mascara again because it made my picking worse. Mascara always felt heavy on my eyelashes, like something was stuck in them and I had to get it off.
I tried this for the first time today and holy crap. I think because it’s not waterproofed that it makes the formula so much lighter. I actually forgot I was using it. I just got ready for bed and looked in the mirror and realized I still had it on. I didn’t pick a single eyelash out all day.”
This unexpected benefit highlights how the lightweight formula and precise application can make a significant difference for those with specific needs.
Value Proposition
At a drugstore price point, many users found this mascara to be an excellent value, comparing it favorably to high-end alternatives:
“I love that it does what it says, that’s rare in make-up products. I have bought very expensive mascara before finding this one. I tried Lancome, Estee Lauder, and Dior which was my favorite one before finding this one.”
“I’ve tried everything from $50 mascaras to Dollar Tree mascaras and this is so far one of my favorites.”
The affordable price point makes it accessible for most consumers and allows for regular replacement, which is important for eye health.
Potential Drawbacks
Sensitivity Issues
While many users found this mascara to be gentle on sensitive eyes, a small number reported irritation:
“I really liked the comb/brush. It gets right down to the root and separates each lash nicely. The only problem was it made my eyes burn like crazy!”
“This mascara burned my eyes and made my eyelids itchy and slightly swollen after only a couple of uses.”
As with any eye product, individual sensitivities can vary, so those with particularly reactive eyes might want to proceed with caution.
Drying Time
Some users found the formula to be on the wetter side, requiring patience during application:
“I did comparison and side by side it looks almost identical to the Essence but is NOT as thick. So lacking just a bit in volume, but still a great product.”
“It took much longer to dry compared to what I am used to.”
This might be a consideration for those who are typically in a rush during their morning routine.
Learning Curve
As mentioned earlier, the unique applicator does require some getting used to:
“The wand is VERY thin. Almost like a brush you would expect to see specifically for lower lashes. However, when I applied the mascara I was pleasantly surprised.”
For those who prefer a more traditional application experience, this could be a deterrent.
Comparison to Other Maybelline Mascaras
Several reviewers compared this mascara to other products in the Maybelline line:
“This mascara applies great and I like the way my lashes look with it. But it flakes and falls off under my eyes not long after applying it. I haven’t had this happen with Sky High or Lash Sensational.”
“Reminiscent of Lash Stylist which was my all-time favorite mascara that Maybelline discontinued.”
Many users seem to be loyal to the Maybelline brand but switch between different products in their line depending on the specific look they’re trying to achieve.
Who Should Try This Mascara?
Based on the reviews, this mascara would be particularly well-suited for:
- Those seeking length and definition rather than volume: If your primary goal is longer, well-separated lashes, this could be your perfect match.
- People with fine, sparse, or difficult-to-reach lashes: The precision applicator makes it ideal for targeting even the smallest lashes.
- Bottom lash enthusiasts: The thin wand is perfect for coating bottom lashes without creating a mess.
- Those who prefer a more natural look: While buildable, this mascara tends to create a more natural, feathery effect rather than dramatic volume.
- People who hate removing waterproof mascara: The washable formula comes off easily while still offering decent staying power.
Who Might Want to Skip It?
This might not be the best choice for:
- Volume seekers: If your primary goal is thick, voluminous lashes, you might need to layer this with another product or choose a different mascara altogether.
- Those who prefer traditional brushes: The learning curve of the comb-like applicator might be frustrating for some.
- People with extremely sensitive eyes: While many found it gentle, there were some reports of irritation.
- Those seeking dramatic, one-step results: This mascara tends to create a more natural look unless built up with multiple coats.
Final Verdict
Maybelline’s Falsies Push Up Angel Washable Mascara in Very Black is an innovative product that delivers on many of its promises. Its unique applicator offers precision and control that traditional mascara wands can’t match, particularly for lengthening and defining lashes.
While it may not be perfect for everyone – particularly those seeking significant volume – it excels at creating separated, lifted lashes with a natural yet enhanced appearance. The washable formula makes it practical for everyday use, and the affordable price point makes it accessible to most consumers.
For those willing to embrace the learning curve of the unique applicator, this mascara offers a fresh approach to lash enhancement that many find superior to traditional options. It’s particularly valuable for those with fine, sparse lashes or anyone who struggles with applying mascara to bottom lashes.
Overall Rating: 4.2/5 stars
The Falsies Push Up Angel earns high marks for innovation, precision, and value, with slight deductions for the learning curve and potential flaking issues with multiple coats.
Whether this becomes your new holy grail mascara or just another product in your rotation will likely depend on your specific lash needs and preferred look – but at its price point, it’s certainly worth trying to find out if angel wings are in your future.
Buy on Amazon: Here