Hey beauty lovers! Today I’m breaking down EVERYTHING about Maybelline’s Fit Me Liquid Concealer in Café. After analyzing tons of real reviews and putting this drugstore staple through its paces, I’ve got the complete lowdown on whether this budget-friendly concealer is worth your coins.
First Impressions & Packaging
Let’s be honest – the packaging isn’t winning any innovation awards. It comes in a simple clear tube with a standard doe-foot applicator that some reviewers mentioned is on the smaller side. One user specifically noted: “I love this concealer. I just wish they would update the applicator. It’s tiny so you have to use more product.”
The size is definitely on the small side (several users mentioned wishing it came in a larger bottle), but the flip side? This little tube can last FOREVER. One reviewer reported their tube lasted an impressive one year and eight months with 3-4 uses per week! Talk about getting your money’s worth.
Shade Range & Color Match
Café specifically is a deeper shade that works beautifully for medium-dark to dark skin tones. Many WOC (women of color) in the reviews emphasized how well it matched their skin tone:
“This concealer is perfect for my mocha/cocoa skin tone.”
“Just received it today, I applied it with my whole makeup routine and it blended really well with my foundation, so happy and excited to finally find my shade.”
Something to note: There seems to be some confusion about the numbering system. Some reviews mentioned that “Café has been changed from #30 to #50 but it’s still FIRE!!!!!” So if you’re ordering online, be aware there might be inconsistencies in how the shade is labeled.
A few users did mention the shade being different than expected – either darker or lighter than anticipated. This is the classic online makeup shopping dilemma, so if you’re between shades, you might want to check it out in-store first.
Formula & Consistency
This is where opinions get REALLY interesting! The consistency seems to be on the thinner, more lightweight side. Some users LOVE this aspect:
“It’s not too heavy, very light but still creamy enough to conceal.”
“Very natural concealer, brings a subtle highlight to my brown skin.”
Others found it TOO thin for their preferences:
“This product is so thin I have to double up on application when I use it. This is the thinnest concealer I’ve ever used in my life.”
“A bit watery and not meant for full coverage.”
The formula is definitely oil-free, which many reviewers with oily skin appreciated. However, if you have dry skin, especially under the eyes, you might need to prep properly: “Definitely need a primer or moisturizer underneath this.”
Coverage & Finish
The Fit Me concealer offers what most described as light to medium, buildable coverage with a natural finish. It’s not a full-coverage formula that will completely mask severe discoloration in one swipe, but many users found it perfect for everyday wear:
“I find that it is very pigmented and that a little bit of product goes a long way, so you never need to use too much at once.”
“Natural to medium coverage and looks like skin”
The finish tends toward natural rather than matte or dewy, with one reviewer noting it “leaves my skin very fresh, breathing, natural.”
Application & Blendability
This is where the Fit Me concealer seems to REALLY shine. Multiple reviewers raved about how easily it blends:
“Blends seamlessly to cover under-eye circles & imperfections.”
“It blends very well but it seems more like a highlighter than concealer.”
“Ok I really like this for a contour/bronzer situation. Literally melts into the skin and blends so effortlessly and flawlessly.”
The thin consistency makes it blend easily, though some suggested letting it sit for a moment before blending: “I do have to allow time for it to dry before I even things out with my foundation and sponge.”
One interesting note: A reviewer mentioned: “When using this concealer I don’t really wait before blending it out because it’s pretty hard to blend even when it was just applied.” This contradicts other experiences, suggesting technique and skin type might play a role in blendability.
Versatility & Uses
What surprised me most was how VERSATILE this product is! While marketed as a concealer, users found multiple creative applications:
- Traditional concealer: “This is the best concealer I have found so far for covering my under eyes that doesn’t crease too much.”
- Cream contour: “Girl I use this for cream contour and it’s sooo good. I don’t really like it for concealer… This is my 3rd time repurchasing the Maybelline Fit Me concealer in a dark brown color. I use it strictly for cream contour and it elevates tf out of my glam.”
- Brow clean-up: “This is fantastic for cleaning up my eyebrows after filling them in. I’ve been using this concealer for my brows everyday since I got it.”
- Highlighting: “I use this for highlighting under my eyes and cleaning up my eyebrows when I fill them in.”
- Specific spot coverage: “I have small white spots of vitiligo around my mouth and needed just some small coverage… I like how the wand allows me to be precise.”
Longevity & Wear
How does it hold up throughout the day? For most reviewers, pretty darn well! Many mentioned it offers all-day wear, especially when set properly:
“It’s also been easy to wash and wipe away by the end of the day. It’s given me an all day stay.”
“This is the only concealer I use for highlighting my under eye area. It is easy to blend, has just the right amount of coverage and most importantly it stays put for the whole day! I set it with Ben Nye banana powder and I am good for a whole day. No creasing, nothing.”
One pro tip from a long-time user: “Best advice because of its lightweight feature is to let it ‘bake’ with face powder before applying your foundation for maximum hold and that matte finish.”
A few noted issues with creasing, which is common with under-eye concealer in general, but many found it creased less than other options.
Skin Compatibility
The formula seems to work well for most skin types, though there were specific notes:
- Oily skin: “I have oily skin so I like that it’s lightweight but gives me amazing coverage without settling into my pores or creases.”
- Dry skin: “Perfect for dry skin… stay away if you’re oily.” (This contradicts other reviews from oily-skinned users who loved it, so your mileage may vary!)
- Sensitive skin: Several users mentioned no breakouts or irritation, with one noting: “I have not broken out.”
One interesting note about pairing with other products: “This concealer cannot be paired with the Smooth+Dewy Fit Me Foundation. Since the foundation itself is quite ‘wet’ when you first put it on, if you put the concealer on immediately after the foundation, it doesn’t stick.”
Comparisons to Higher-End Products
Several reviewers compared this affordable option to higher-end concealers:
“This product is often compared to Nars, and I agree.”
“Got the wrong shade, but this is one of my favorite concealers!! Dupe for Nars creamy radiant concealer.”
“Great coverage, not heavy and lasts long. I used to use Elizabeth Arden concealer, until they discontinued my perfect tone.”
Value for Money
At drugstore prices, most users found this concealer to be an EXCELLENT value, especially considering how long it lasts. Though one user did note: “the price has nearly doubled since the first time I bought it, and I’m not sure why.”
The Bottom Line: Who Should Buy This?
Based on all the reviews, the Maybelline Fit Me Concealer in Café seems perfect for:
- Those seeking a lightweight, natural-looking concealer
- Medium to dark skin tones looking for a good match
- People who prefer buildable rather than full coverage
- Anyone wanting a versatile product for concealing, contouring, or highlighting
- Makeup users who value easy blendability
- Those on a budget seeking a quality drugstore option
It might NOT be the best choice for:
- Those seeking full, heavy coverage in one layer
- People with extremely dry under-eyes (without proper prep)
- Anyone who prefers a thick, creamy consistency
Final Thoughts
Is the Maybelline Fit Me Concealer in Café worth trying? ABSOLUTELY! It’s a versatile, budget-friendly option that performs well beyond its price point for many users. Its natural finish, easy blendability, and long wear time make it a staple in many makeup collections.
The thin consistency might not be for everyone, but if you prefer a lightweight concealer that looks like skin while still providing decent coverage, this could be your new holy grail. And at drugstore prices, it’s definitely worth taking a chance on!
Have you tried the Maybelline Fit Me Concealer? I’d love to hear YOUR experiences with it in the comments below!
Buy on Amazon: Here
