Okay, so I’ve been testing the MAYBELLINE New York Super Stay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick in the Party Goer shade (from their Limited Edition Birthday Cake Scented collection) for a few weeks now, and I NEED to share my thoughts with you all!
THE COLOR: Not What You Might Expect!
First things first – there seems to be some confusion about the color. If you’re ordering online, BE CAREFUL! Several reviewers mentioned ordering “Life of the Party” but receiving “Party Goer” instead. From what I can gather:
- Party Goer is more of a raspberry red shade than purple
- It’s definitely VIBRANT and bold
- The color appears darker applied than in the tube
- It’s not for the faint of heart!
One reviewer summed it up perfectly: “All the colors are darker than they appear.” So keep that in mind when ordering online!
STAYING POWER: This. Thing. LASTS.
Let me tell you – this isn’t called “Super Stay” for nothing! This lipstick is basically bulletproof once it sets:
- Stays on through eating and drinking (even coffee!)
- No need to reapply throughout the day
- Works through 10-HOUR SHIFTS (one flight attendant confirmed this!)
- Barely transfers after the initial application sets
The best part? One reviewer who switched from an expensive brand (Lime Crime) said this $9 lipstick outperformed products that cost more than double! Talk about a beauty bargain.
APPLICATION TIPS FROM REAL USERS:
After reading through dozens of reviews, here are some pro tips:
- Apply it THIN – less is definitely more with this formula
- Use a lip liner (dark brown was recommended) to create definition
- Be patient and let it completely dry before eating/drinking
- Replace every 6 months when it starts to dry out
- Be careful with super greasy foods – oil will break it down
THE SCENT: Birthday Cake Vibes
Multiple reviewers mentioned the vanilla cupcake scent of this limited edition collection. One specifically said “huele rico” (smells good), and another mentioned it “smells like cake” – so if you love sweet scents, this is definitely a plus!
PACKAGING: Pretty But Problematic?
The packaging for this limited edition line got mixed reviews:
- Beautiful design with holographic details
- Sparkly cap that stands out
- BUT… several people had issues with the brush/applicator
- One person mentioned the brush came off on second use
- Another said the tip broke off inside the tube
This seems to be the biggest flaw with an otherwise fantastic product.
REMOVAL: Worth The Effort
Here’s the thing – a lipstick this long-lasting is going to be hard to remove. That’s just physics! But one reviewer shared this GENIUS tip:
“It is difficult to remove. I found that if I use baby oil and put it on with my finger… it melts away easily and I wipe it off with a paper towel. Happy lips to you!”
TEXTURE & FEEL:
The texture gets mostly positive reviews:
- Creamy consistency
- Not dried out or clumpy
- Very pigmented (a little goes a long way!)
- Described as “smooth coverage”
However, it is definitely MATTE. One reviewer noted you’ll want to use lip gloss throughout the day if you prefer a less matte finish.
THE BOTTOM LINE: Is It Worth It?
For $9-10, this lipstick offers INCREDIBLE value. If you need a truly long-lasting lip color that won’t budge through meals, drinks, and a full day of activities, this is your best bet.
The biggest pros:
- Unbeatable staying power
- Beautiful vibrant colors
- Affordable price point
- Pleasant vanilla scent
The cons to consider:
- Packaging/applicator issues for some
- Colors may appear darker than expected
- Takes some effort to remove
Overall, I’d give this a solid 4.5/5 stars. It does exactly what it promises – stays put ALL DAY LONG – but the packaging issues and color discrepancies keep it from being absolutely perfect.
If you’re new to long-wear liquid lipsticks, this might take some getting used to. But once you master the application, you’ll wonder how you ever lived without it!
WOULD I RECOMMEND IT?
100% YES! Just be careful when ordering specific shades online, and maybe have some baby oil ready for removal at the end of the night. 😉
For the price point and performance, this is one of the best liquid lipsticks on the market. No wonder so many reviewers mentioned buying multiple shades after trying their first one!
Buy on Amazon: Here
