Hey there! So I’ve been using this Maybelline Falsies mascara in Black Drama for MONTHS now, and I figured it’s about time I shared my thoughts. If you’re wondering whether this drugstore mascara is worth adding to your makeup bag, I’ve got you covered!
First Impressions
Let’s talk packaging first – that iconic purple tube with the silver wings on the lid is pretty recognizable. The brush is what Maybelline calls a “spoon brush” which is slightly curved to hug your lash line. It’s definitely on the larger side compared to some other mascaras, which might be a pro or con depending on your preference.
When I first pulled the wand out, I noticed the formula isn’t too wet or too dry – it’s that perfect middle consistency that makes application easy. The color (Black Drama) is SUPER black, which I love for making my eyes pop.
Application Experience
The application process is pretty straightforward but does require a little practice if you’re new to this specific brush. The curved spoon shape helps grab all your lashes from root to tip, but you might need to be careful with the inner corner lashes since the brush is fairly large.
One thing I’ve noticed is that this mascara builds really well. One coat gives a nice natural look with added length, but you can easily layer 2-3 coats to get that dramatic “falsies” effect the name promises. Just don’t wait too long between coats or it might clump.
The Results: Does It Really Look Like Falsies?
Okay, let’s get real – does it ACTUALLY make your lashes look like falsies? I’d say it comes pretty darn close for a drugstore mascara! The lengthening effect is impressive, and it definitely adds volume too.
Several reviewers mentioned getting asked if they were wearing fake lashes, and I’ve had similar experiences. My natural lashes are pretty average – not super short but not naturally long either. With two coats of this mascara, they look dramatically longer and fuller.
The curved brush really helps lift the lashes too, which adds to that wide-eyed, falsies effect. I’ve found I can often skip using an eyelash curler when I’m using this mascara, which is a huge time-saver.
Staying Power
For a non-waterproof formula, the staying power is actually pretty good! It lasts through my 8-hour workday without major issues. However, there are some common complaints I’ve experienced too:
- Flaking: After several hours (especially in drier weather), I sometimes notice little black flakes under my eyes. It’s not terrible, but definitely something to be aware of.
- Smudging: If you have oily eyelids like me, you might experience some smudging by the end of the day. Not raccoon eyes level, but noticeable.
The waterproof version seems to have better staying power based on other reviews, so that might be a better option if you need your mascara to last through sweaty workouts, emotional movies, or rainy days!
Removal Process
One major PLUS of the washable formula is how easily it comes off! No aggressive rubbing or special makeup removers needed – just warm water and facial cleanser does the trick. This is honestly one of my favorite things about this mascara since I HATE when mascaras are stubborn to remove and I end up losing lashes in the process.
Some reviewers mentioned having raccoon eyes during removal, which is true – it does get a bit messy during washing. I usually use a separate makeup remover before cleansing just to avoid the black streaks all over my face.
Value for Money
At around $8-10 depending on where you buy it, this mascara is an absolute STEAL compared to high-end options. Several reviewers mentioned switching from expensive brands like Benefit’s “They’re Real” (which costs about 3x more) and finding this mascara performed just as well or better!
I’ve had my tube for about 3 months of regular use, and it’s still going strong without drying out, which is impressive for the price point.
The Downsides
Let’s be honest – no product is perfect, and this one has a few drawbacks:
- The formula can be a bit clumpy if you apply too much at once or if you don’t wipe excess product off the wand.
- Some reviewers reported receiving dry batches, especially when ordering online.
- The brush size is quite large, which can make application tricky for those with smaller eyes.
- The flaking issue is real for some people (though not everyone experiences it).
- It’s not the best choice if you need something that can withstand tears, sweat, or rain without the waterproof version.
Who Would Love This Mascara?
This mascara is perfect for:
- People who want dramatic lashes without the hassle of falsies
- Anyone looking for a budget-friendly mascara that performs like high-end options
- Those who prefer easy removal at the end of the day
- People with average to long natural lashes who want to enhance what they have
If you have very short or very sparse lashes, you might find this gives good length but may need to be paired with a volumizing primer to get the full falsies effect.
The Comparison Game
A lot of reviewers compared this to other popular mascaras:
- Many found it performed BETTER than Benefit’s “They’re Real” at a fraction of the cost
- Some prefer it over L’Oreal’s Million Lashes, though others like to layer both
- A few compared it favorably to Too Faced “Better Than Sex” mascara as a great dupe
I’ve personally tried a bunch of high-end mascaras, and I keep coming back to this one. That says a lot!
Tips for Best Results
After using this for months and reading through tons of reviews, here are some pro tips for getting the most out of this mascara:
- Wipe excess product off the brush before applying to avoid clumps
- Apply in thin layers, building up gradually rather than loading on too much at once
- Try combining it with other mascaras – some reviewers loved using Million Lashes first for separation, then Falsies on top for length
- If you experience flaking, setting your under-eye area with a bit of translucent powder can help
- For maximum drama, focus on the outer lashes and build more product there
Alternative Options Within the Line
It’s worth noting that there are several variations of the Falsies mascara:
- The original Falsies (purple tube with silver writing)
- Falsies Black Drama (the one I’m reviewing)
- Falsies Waterproof
- Falsies Push Up Drama (in a red tube)
Several reviewers mentioned preferring the original Falsies formula over the Black Drama, claiming it was less prone to clumping. If you’re experiencing issues with the Black Drama version, it might be worth trying the original!
The Bottom Line
Would I recommend Maybelline Volum’ Express The Falsies mascara? ABSOLUTELY! Despite its few flaws, it delivers impressive results at a price point that can’t be beat.
For everyday dramatic lashes without the hassle of actual falsies, this has become my go-to. It’s the mascara I keep coming back to even when I try fancier, more expensive options.
The lengthening power is impressive, the formula builds well, and removal is a breeze. Just be prepared for potential flaking if you have a particularly long day ahead.
Overall Rating: 4.5/5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐½
What’s fantastic:
- Dramatic length and volume
- Budget-friendly price
- Easy removal
- Super black color
What could be better:
- Some flaking throughout the day
- Potential for clumping if not applied carefully
- Large brush can be tricky for smaller eyes
Have you tried this mascara? I’d love to hear your experience with it! And if you have any questions about it that I didn’t cover, just let me know in the comments!
Happy makeup-ing, friends! 💋
Buy on Amazon: Here
