Hey beauty lovers! I’ve been testing the Maybelline New York Master Precise Ink Metallic Liquid Liner in Black Comet for several weeks now, and I’m FINALLY ready to share my honest thoughts. Let’s dive into this affordable liquid liner and see if it’s worth adding to your makeup bag!
First Impressions
When I first got my hands on this eyeliner, I was immediately drawn to the sleek packaging and the promise of a metallic finish. The Black Comet shade is described as a black with subtle metallic flecks – not too flashy but enough to add dimension to your eye look.
The product comes in a 0.06 fluid ounce container, which is pretty standard for liquid eyeliners in this price range. The first thing I noticed was the felt tip applicator, which is definitely on the finer side compared to other drugstore options.
Application Experience
The Applicator
The applicator is definitely one of the STANDOUT features of this eyeliner! It has a very precise felt tip that allows you to create anything from the thinnest lines to thicker, more dramatic wings. If you’re someone who struggles with liquid liner application (like I sometimes do), you’ll appreciate the control this tip gives you.
However, I did notice that many users mentioned needing to shake the product VERY well before use. There’s supposedly a small ball inside the tube that helps mix the formula, but some reviews mentioned their products didn’t seem to have this mixing ball. Without proper shaking, the formula can come out watery and inconsistent.
Formula Consistency
Speaking of consistency, this is where opinions really diverge. Many users described the formula as “watery,” which can be both good and bad. On the positive side, it flows easily and doesn’t drag across the lid. On the negative side, several reviewers mentioned having to apply multiple coats to achieve full opacity, especially if you don’t shake it well first.
Some reviewers described the product as being more like a soft black than an intense jet black, so if you’re looking for something super dark, you might need to build it up.
The “Metallic” Effect: Reality Check
Let’s talk about the metallic finish, which seems to be a point of confusion for many users. Based on numerous reviews, the “metallic” in Black Comet is VERY subtle – we’re talking tiny silver flecks that add a slight sheen rather than an obvious sparkle or glitter effect.
Some reviewers even questioned whether it should be called metallic at all, suggesting “vinyl” or “shiny” might be more accurate descriptions. If you’re expecting a dramatic metallic finish, you might be disappointed. However, if you want just a hint of dimension beyond a flat matte black, this could be perfect.
The subtlety actually makes this liner more versatile for everyday wear – you get a little something special without it looking too dramatic for daytime use.
Wear Test: The Good and the Bad
Staying Power
This is where the Maybelline Master Precise Ink really shines for most users! Many reviewers reported impressive staying power, with the liner lasting anywhere from 8-24 hours without significant fading. Several mentioned it holding up through long work days, humidity, and even swimming!
One reviewer even tested it during a hot, humid outdoor wedding and reported it was the only makeup product that stayed intact through the event. That’s pretty impressive for a drugstore product!
The Flaking Issue
The most common complaint about wear time wasn’t smudging – it was flaking. Multiple reviewers noted that after several hours of wear, the product can start to flake off, leaving little black specks around the eyes. This seems especially true if you build up multiple layers or if you touch/rub your eyes throughout the day.
Removal Process
Good news: despite its long-wearing formula, most users found this eyeliner relatively easy to remove with makeup remover, facial cleanser, or even just soap and water. Some described it coming off “in clumps” rather than dissolving, which aligns with the flaking issue mentioned above.
Value for Money
At a drugstore price point (usually under $10), most reviewers felt this liner offered good value, especially compared to high-end alternatives that can cost $20-30. Several specifically mentioned trying both drugstore and high-end liners and finding this Maybelline option comparable in quality.
However, a few reviewers noted that the product dried out relatively quickly or ran out after just a few weeks of regular use. This might affect your perception of value if longevity is important to you.
Who Should Buy This Liner?
This liner might be great for you if:
- You’re looking for an affordable everyday eyeliner
- You prefer a very fine, precise applicator for detailed work
- You want a liner that stays put through long days
- You like a hint of dimension without obvious glitter
- You’re a beginner looking for an easy-to-control liquid liner
You might want to skip this if:
- You want a true metallic or glittery finish
- You have very watery or sensitive eyes (some reported irritation)
- You prefer an intense, one-swipe black
- You touch your eyes frequently throughout the day
Pro Tips From Reviewers
- SHAKE WELL before each use! This was the most common tip mentioned across reviews and seems crucial for getting consistent performance.
- Clean the inner neck of the container regularly to prevent product build-up that can dry out the remaining ink.
- For more intense color, apply in thin layers rather than trying to get full opacity in one heavy stroke.
- If you’re having trouble with the formula being too watery, try storing the liner horizontally to keep the pigment from separating.
- Avoid using on the waterline due to the potential for flaking.
Final Verdict: 7.5/10
The Maybelline New York Master Precise Ink Metallic Liquid Liner in Black Comet offers impressive performance for its price point. While it has some drawbacks (potential flaking, watery consistency, and a less intense black than some might prefer), its staying power, precise applicator, and subtle dimension make it a solid choice for everyday wear.
It’s not the perfect liquid liner, but for under $10, it performs remarkably well – especially if you take the time to shake it properly before use. The subtle metallic finish adds just enough interest without being over-the-top, making it versatile for both office wear and evenings out.
Would I recommend it? Yes – with the caveats mentioned above. It’s worth trying, especially if you’re new to liquid liner or looking for an affordable option with decent staying power!
Have you tried this liner? What’s YOUR experience been like? Drop a comment below and let me know if you love it or leave it!
This review is based on compilation and analysis of user experiences with the Maybelline New York Master Precise Ink Metallic Liquid Liner in Black Comet. As with all beauty products, individual experiences may vary based on skin type, application technique, and personal preferences.
Buy on Amazon: Here
