Let me just start by saying this – I’ve been testing makeup removers for YEARS and this one has seriously stood the test of time! After analyzing countless reviews and incorporating my own expertise, I’m breaking down everything you need to know about this cult classic.
The Short Version
PROS:
- AMAZING at removing waterproof mascara (the real standout feature)
- Long-lasting bottle (a little goes a long way!)
- Budget-friendly compared to department store brands
- Gentle on sensitive skin and eyes
- No lash loss during removal
- Quick and effective
CONS:
- Oil-based formula (problematic for some users)
- Can cause blurry vision if you wear contacts
- Some find it messy to use
- Creates residue that may require secondary cleansing
The Full Deep-Dive
What’s This Product All About?
Maybelline’s Expert Eyes Makeup Remover has been around FOREVER – and for good reason! This dual-pack of removers is specifically formulated to tackle stubborn eye makeup, particularly waterproof mascara that normally requires excessive rubbing (hello, damaged lashes!).
The clear, oil-based formula comes in a simple plastic bottle with a flip-top cap. Nothing fancy here – it’s all about function over form. Each bottle contains enough product to last for months of daily use, making the 2-pack an excellent value proposition.
Performance: Let’s Talk Results
The STANDOUT feature of this remover is how efficiently it handles waterproof mascara. If you’ve ever struggled with raccoon eyes after washing your face or found yourself tugging at stubborn mascara, you’ll appreciate how quickly this breaks down even the most persistent formulas.
Application is straightforward – most users recommend:
- Pouring a small amount into your palm
- Using fingertips to massage it directly onto lashes/makeup
- Wiping away with a washcloth or cotton pad
What’s impressive is how FAST it works. Unlike some removers that require soaking and multiple applications, this starts dissolving makeup on contact. Many long-term users mention they’ve tried various high-end alternatives but keep coming back to this because nothing else works as effectively.
The Texture Experience
Let’s address the elephant in the room – this is definitely an oil-based formula. This is both its superpower AND its biggest drawback.
The oil base is what makes it so effective at breaking down waterproof formulas. However, it does leave a residue that some users find uncomfortable. Several reviewers mention following up with a facial cleanser to remove the oily feeling, while others incorporate it into their pre-shower routine so it washes away naturally.
If you’re expecting a water-based, non-residue formula, this isn’t it. But the tradeoff is EFFECTIVENESS. As one reviewer put it: “Excellent at getting the most difficult waterproof mascara off. Oily but I just use it before showering, so it washes off anyway.”
Skin Gentleness Factor
For a product targeting such a sensitive area, gentleness matters. Multiple reviews highlight that this remover doesn’t cause irritation, even for those with sensitive eyes or dry skin. The moisturizing properties actually help prevent the dryness that can come from repeated makeup removal.
Long-term users specifically mention that it doesn’t cause lash loss – a common issue with aggressive removers that require excessive rubbing or contain harsh ingredients.
However, there IS one significant issue for contact lens wearers. Several reports mention blurry vision after use, with one reviewer noting: “What is a real dealbreaker for me is that almost every single time I use this product, I have to take out my contacts because my vision just gets way too blurry.”
If you wear contacts, you’ll likely want to remove them before using this product or consider a non-oil alternative.
Application Tips From Experienced Users
Based on the collective wisdom of reviewers, here are some pro tips:
- Use BEFORE showering to naturally rinse away residue
- Apply with fingertips directly to lashes rather than cotton pads (less product waste)
- For stubborn liner, apply and let it sit for 15-30 seconds before wiping
- Follow with a gentle cleanser if the oil bothers you
- Keep away from contact lenses!
Value Proposition
This is where the Maybelline remover truly shines. Multiple reviewers emphasized that they’ve tried department store and luxury brand alternatives costing 3-5 times more, only to return to this affordable option because it simply works better.
As one reviewer stated: “This makeup remover works great without irritating my eyes and is less expensive than the other department store or name brand products.”
Additionally, many mention how long each bottle lasts: “I was glad to be able to find this, I’ve used it forever. I really didn’t want to purchase two, as it lasts a long time, but that was OK.” The fact that a little goes a long way enhances the already budget-friendly price point.
The Loyalty Factor
One of the most telling aspects of the reviews is the extraordinary customer loyalty. Phrases like “I’ve been using this for years,” “used this product for longer than I can remember,” and “been using this for about 50 years, no exaggeration” appear repeatedly.
This level of loyalty speaks volumes. In an industry where new products launch constantly with promises of revolutionary results, having customers who return to the same product for decades is remarkable.
Several reviewers expressed frustration about occasional difficulty finding it in stores, with one stating: “My local store never has this in stock. It is hands down, the BEST eye makeup remover for waterproof mascara. So glad I found it here!”
Who Should Avoid This Product?
While the reviews are predominantly positive, this remover isn’t for everyone:
- If you HATE oil-based products, you probably won’t enjoy the texture
- Contact lens wearers may struggle with blurry vision
- Those seeking an all-in-one face and eye makeup remover might find this too specialized
- If you prefer makeup removing wipes or micellar waters for convenience, the liquid application may feel dated
One reviewer summarized their negative experience: “I really don’t like it. It just like oil, when I put it on my cotton pads, trying to remove my makeup. It just like I am going to add oil on my face. I will never buy it again.”
Comparison to Similar Products
Several reviewers mentioned trying alternatives, with Estée Lauder’s “Take It Away” being the only one cited as comparable in effectiveness – though at a much higher price point. The consensus seems to be that drugstore alternatives generally don’t perform as well, especially on waterproof formulas.
One interesting comment compared it favorably to newer micellar waters: “No fancy pads and cleans eye makeup off quickly and completely.”
Historical Context: A Product With Heritage
A fascinating aspect of this remover is its longevity in the market. Multiple reviewers expressed concern about potential discontinuation: “I am upset to find that the company is no longer making this product – why????? Sometimes I think they don’t care about all the years this product has been used by their customers.”
This suggests it’s not just effective but has developed a genuine emotional connection with customers – something rare in the disposable world of beauty products.
Final Verdict
The Maybelline New York Expert Eyes Moisturizing Eye Makeup Remover earns 4.5/5 stars in my book. It delivers exceptional performance for its price point, with its only significant drawbacks being the oily residue (which is actually the source of its effectiveness) and potential issues for contact lens wearers.
If you:
- Regularly wear waterproof mascara or stubborn eye makeup
- Prioritize effectiveness over fancy packaging
- Are on a budget but don’t want to compromise on results
- Have sensitive eyes that need gentle but thorough cleaning
…then this should ABSOLUTELY be your go-to remover!
For decades, this product has quietly outperformed countless trendy alternatives. While beauty brands continuously launch new “revolutionary” formulas with inflated prices, this humble bottle continues to deliver exactly what it promises – clean lashes without the hassle.
Sometimes the classics really are classics for a reason!
Buy on Amazon: Here
