Hey beauty lovers! Today I’m diving into one of the most talked-about drugstore powders on the market – the Maybelline New York Fit Me Loose Finishing Powder in Medium. After using this for months and seeing TONS of reviews from others, I’ve got some thoughts to share!
First Impressions
Right out of the box, this powder comes in a simple plastic container with a sifter top. No fancy packaging here, folks – just the basics. But let’s be real, who needs fancy packaging when the product inside is what matters?
One thing to note – there’s no applicator included. No brush, no puff, nothing. You’ll need to bring your own tools to the party. Not a huge deal at the price point (seriously, it’s SUCH a bargain), but worth mentioning if you’re new to makeup.
Application Experience
The powder itself is incredibly fine and lightweight. It practically floats onto the skin! I typically use a fluffy powder brush for all-over setting and a smaller, more dense brush for under-eye baking or targeted oil control.
A little tip about opening it for first-timers: some reviewers mentioned struggling with the clear plastic cover inside. There’s a small tab you can grab – just pull slowly and it’ll come off. If product is stuck in the holes, tap it gently on a table to clear it.
Coverage & Finish
This is where the Fit Me powder REALLY shines. The coverage is impressive for a finishing powder – it can be built up from sheer to medium coverage depending on your application technique.
The finish is beautifully matte without looking flat or cakey. My skin looks genuinely flawless when I use this – it blurs those annoying fine lines under my eyes and on my forehead like MAGIC! One reviewer mentioned their skin looked 10 years younger, and I have to agree.
For a $3-4 powder, the quality is UNBELIEVABLE. I’ve used high-end finishing powders that don’t perform nearly as well.
Shade Range & Match
The Medium shade is pretty versatile and works well for light-medium to medium skin tones with neutral to warm undertones. According to several reviewers (including one Native American user with neutral/warm undertones), it blends seamlessly into the skin.
I’ve found that the shade names can be a bit deceiving though. Some users mentioned needing to try a couple different shades before finding their perfect match. If you’re between shades, I’d recommend going a touch lighter as it can oxidize slightly throughout the day.
Staying Power
In terms of longevity, this powder holds up remarkably well in most conditions. Even in hot, humid weather (which is the ultimate test for any powder!), it keeps oil at bay for several hours before needing a touch-up.
One reviewer who lives in the South mentioned it stood up to their hot climate for 9 months of the year – impressive! However, it does have one weakness: water. If you tend to have watery eyes or get caught in rain, be aware that the powder will wash away on contact with moisture.
For Different Skin Types
Oily Skin
This is an absolute GODSEND for oily skin types! Multiple reviewers with oily skin mentioned how well it controls shine without drying out the skin. One user specifically mentioned having very sensitive and oily skin and had no problems with this powder all day long.
Dry Skin
While primarily marketed for normal to oily skin, several users with drier skin found it worked well when applied with a light hand. It doesn’t emphasize dry patches as much as some other matte powders can.
Sensitive Skin
Good news for those with reactive skin – many reviewers mentioned having sensitive skin and experiencing no breakouts or irritation. One user specifically noted that they had no signs of acne or clogged pores when they removed their makeup at the end of the day.
Versatility
What I love most about this powder is how versatile it is. You can use it in so many ways:
- Over foundation as a setting powder
- Under eyes to “bake” concealer
- On bare skin with just moisturizer for a natural, even look
- For touch-ups throughout the day
- Even over sunscreen for a matte finish without foundation
Several reviewers mentioned using it directly over moisturizer without foundation for a natural look, which is perfect for those minimal makeup days when you just want to look put together without a full face.
Comparison to High-End Options
Multiple users compared this to high-end powders, with several claiming it outperforms them. One reviewer specifically mentioned it performs better than department store “sister brands” at a fraction of the price.
Another mentioned they had tried “several expensive brands” before discovering this powder and found the Maybelline option superior in performance. For those looking to save money without sacrificing quality, this seems like a no-brainer.
Potential Downsides
No product is perfect, so let’s talk about the few complaints I found:
- Color Selection: Some reviewers mentioned the shade descriptions can be misleading, requiring some trial and error to find the right match.
- Water Resistance: As mentioned earlier, this powder does not hold up well against moisture. One user specifically noted it washes away with tears if you have watery eyes.
- Undertones: A few users mentioned the Medium shade can appear slightly yellow on some skin tones.
- Coverage for Dark Circles: While it works well for general setting, one reviewer mentioned it doesn’t provide enough coverage for very dark under-eye circles.
- Transfer: One user noted that it does transfer somewhat, which is something to be aware of if you’re wearing light-colored clothing.
Value for Money
At roughly $3-4 per container (price varies by retailer), the value is INCREDIBLE. You get 0.7 ounces of product, which lasts for months even with daily use. Several reviewers mentioned purchasing multiple shades for different seasons given the affordable price point.
One user mentioned buying two different shades (for winter and summer) for just $6 total – a fraction of what you’d pay for high-end alternatives.
Long-Term Use
Many reviewers mentioned they’ve been loyal to this product for years. One specifically said they’d been using it for 5 years as their go-to setting powder, while another called it their “holy grail” product that they keep coming back to.
This kind of long-term loyalty speaks volumes about the consistent quality and performance of the product.
How It Fits Into Your Routine
The Fit Me powder works well with a variety of other products. Reviewers mentioned successfully pairing it with:
- Different foundations
- Tinted moisturizers
- Regular moisturizers alone
- Sunscreen
- Various concealers (specifically Neutrogena concealer was mentioned)
- CC creams
Its versatility makes it easy to incorporate into your existing makeup routine regardless of what other products you use.
Final Thoughts
After using this powder extensively and reading through countless reviews, I’m convinced this is one of the best drugstore beauty products available. It punches WAY above its weight class in terms of performance.
Is it perfect? No. But for the price point, it’s pretty darn close. Whether you’re a makeup newbie on a budget or a seasoned beauty enthusiast looking to save some money without sacrificing quality, the Maybelline Fit Me Loose Finishing Powder deserves a spot in your makeup bag.
If you’re on the fence about trying it – just do it! At this price point, there’s very little risk, and you might just discover your new holy grail powder like so many others have.
Rating Breakdown:
- Quality: 4.5/5
- Value: 5/5
- Longevity: 4/5
- Shade Range: 3.5/5
- Overall: 4.5/5
Have you tried this powder? What’s YOUR experience been like? Drop a comment below!
Buy on Amazon: Here
