Hey beauty lovers! Today I’m diving DEEP into one of the most talked-about long-wear lipsticks on the market – the Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink in shade Originator #1102. I’ve been testing this 2-pack for several weeks now, and I’ve got THOUGHTS!
Quick Stats
- Product: Pack of 2 Maybelline New York SuperStay Matte Ink Liquid Lipstick
- Shade: Originator #1102 (intense purple)
- Claims: Up to 16-hour wear, transfer-proof, highly pigmented
- Price Point: Mid-range drugstore (better value in the 2-pack)
First Impressions
The moment I opened these lipsticks, I was struck by the packaging – it’s sleek and feels more expensive than it actually is. The arrow-shaped applicator is unique and designed to help with precision, which I definitely appreciate for a bold shade like this purple!
The color is STUNNING – a deep, rich purple that makes a statement without looking too costume-y. It’s vibrant but still wearable for someone who’s comfortable with bold lips. This isn’t your everyday neutral, but that’s exactly what makes it special!
Application Experience
Let’s talk about applying this stuff, because it’s NOT like your regular lipstick. The formula is thick – almost like paint – and you need a steady hand. The doe-foot applicator has a pointed tip that helps with precision, but here’s my advice: take your TIME with this one.
I found that working in thin layers works best. Start with your lower lip, then upper, and definitely avoid rubbing your lips together until it’s completely dry (about 1-2 minutes). If you mess up, act FAST – once this sets, it’s not budging without makeup remover!
One thing I noticed right away – this formula has a sweet scent that lingers for about 30 minutes after application. Not unpleasant, but worth mentioning if you’re sensitive to fragrance.
The Wear Test – Does It REALLY Last?
OK so Maybelline claims this lasts up to 16 hours. And based on my testing and the user feedback I gathered – THIS IS NOT AN EXAGGERATION!
One reviewer mentioned it lasted over 20 hours for her daughter, which sounds crazy but I believe it. I wore this through:
- A 9-hour workday
- Lunch (salad and sandwich)
- Coffee (multiple cups!)
- After-work drinks
- Dinner
And guess what? It was still going strong! The center faded slightly after eating oily foods, but the outline remained perfect, which meant no weird ring around my lips.
The BEST part? Zero transfer. None on my coffee cup, none on my napkin, none on my boyfriend’s cheek. This stuff STAYS PUT.
Comfort Factor
Here’s where we need to have an honest conversation. This is NOT the most comfortable formula on the market. The extreme long-wear comes with a trade-off.
When first applied, it feels wet and slightly sticky. Once it dries down (which takes about 2 minutes), it becomes completely transfer-proof but also feels quite tight on the lips. Not painful, but you definitely know you’re wearing lipstick.
After about an hour, it settles in and feels less noticeable, but it never reaches that “I forgot I’m wearing lipstick” comfort level. My lips felt slightly dry by the end of the day, but not terribly so.
One clever hack I learned from a reviewer: applying a clear gloss topcoat (they used Cover Girl) over it once it’s dry. I tried this trick and loved it! You get the longevity of the Matte Ink with added comfort, though it does add a bit of shine to the otherwise perfect matte finish.
The Removal Process
Let me be VERY clear – you will need an oil-based makeup remover to get this off. Water? Laughable. Regular cleanser? Barely makes a dent.
I used micellar water specifically formulated for waterproof makeup, and it worked well with some patience. Coconut oil also works great if you’re in a pinch!
The removal process takes effort, but I actually count this as a positive – it’s proof of how well it stays on throughout the day.
Formula Consistency & Quality Control
Based on my personal experience and the reviews I analyzed, there seem to be some consistency issues between individual tubes. In the 2-pack I received, one tube had a slightly thinner formula than the other. Not a huge deal, but noticeable.
More concerning was one reviewer’s experience with receiving a product where the security seal was broken and the applicator tip was missing entirely. This suggests some quality control issues that Maybelline should address.
The Color Payoff
Originator #1102 is described as a deep purple, and it delivers EXACTLY that. The pigmentation is incredible – one coat gives you full, opaque coverage. The color stays true throughout wear, not oxidizing or changing tone as the day goes on.
The finish is a true matte – no shine whatsoever once dry. This makes it look very modern and editorial, perfect for making a statement.
For those concerned about a purple being too bold, I’d say this particular shade has enough depth to it that it comes across as sophisticated rather than teenage-goth (though you can rock that vibe too if that’s what you’re going for!).
Value for Money
Getting two tubes in one pack is honestly a great deal considering how long each tube lasts. Because the formula is so pigmented, you need very little product per application. I estimate each tube should last 3-4 months with regular use.
Given the performance, I consider this an excellent value. You’d pay three times as much for a high-end lipstick that doesn’t last half as long.
Who Is This Lipstick For?
This is perfect for:
- Anyone who needs truly long-wearing lip color (nurses, teachers, busy parents)
- People who hate touching up makeup throughout the day
- Those who enjoy bold lip colors and making a statement
- Anyone tired of finding lipstick on their coffee cups, straws, or significant others
Maybe skip this if:
- Your lips tend to be very dry (the formula can emphasize dryness)
- You prefer comfort over longevity
- You like to change your lip color multiple times a day (this is NOT coming off easily)
- You’re new to applying liquid lipstick (the learning curve is real)
Specific Situations Where This Lipstick EXCELS
- Weddings and special events – No need to worry about touch-ups during emotional moments or after eating
- Work days – Apply in the morning and forget about it until you get home
- Mask wearing – Though less common now, this formula stays put under masks better than any other I’ve tried
- Date nights – Kiss-proof? Absolutely.
- Vacations – When you want your makeup to last through sightseeing, swimming, and dining out
The Bilingual Appeal
One interesting note from the reviews – this product seems to have a strong following among Spanish-speaking consumers. One reviewer wrote in Spanish about how her daughter adores these lipsticks, mentioning the intense purple color and the impressive 20+ hour wear time.
This cross-cultural appeal speaks to the universal desire for truly long-lasting lip color that performs as promised, regardless of language or background.
Potential Downsides to Consider
In the interest of total honesty, here are the cons:
- The formula can feel drying over extended wear
- Application requires precision and practice
- Removal is time-consuming
- The scent might be off-putting to some
- Possible quality control issues with packaging
- Limited ability to adjust or blend after it sets
Tips and Tricks I’ve Discovered
- Prep is essential – Exfoliate and moisturize lips BEFORE application, then blot any excess moisture
- Less is more – Start with a thin layer; you can always add more
- The clear topcoat hack – As mentioned earlier, adding a clear gloss can increase comfort
- The oil cleanse method – Apply oil to your lips and let it sit for 30 seconds before wiping away for easier removal
- Keep it in the lines – Use a concealer brush to clean up any mistakes IMMEDIATELY after application
- Build your own shade – Mix with other colors in the line before it dries for custom colors
Final Verdict
After weeks of testing, here’s my honest take: Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink in Originator #1102 delivers on its core promise of long-lasting, transfer-proof wear with stunning pigmentation. The 2-pack offers excellent value, though there may be some consistency issues between tubes.
Is it the most comfortable formula? No. But if longevity is your priority, you simply won’t find better performance at this price point. The intense purple shade is gorgeous and versatile enough for various occasions when you want to make a statement.
For me, the pros definitely outweigh the cons. I’m willing to deal with the slightly dry feeling and involved removal process because the color payoff and staying power are UNMATCHED in the drugstore category.
I give this product a solid 4.5/5 stars – with points deducted only for the comfort factor and potential quality control issues.
If you’re tired of lipsticks that disappear after your first sip of coffee, the Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink deserves a spot in your makeup collection. Just be prepared to commit to your lip color choice for the day – this stuff isn’t going ANYWHERE until you decide it should!
Have you tried this lipstick? I’d love to hear your experiences with it – especially if you’ve discovered any application or removal hacks I haven’t mentioned!
Stay beautiful!
Disclaimer: This review is based on personal experience and analysis of user feedback. Individual experiences may vary depending on lip texture, application technique, and personal preferences.
Buy on Amazon: Here
