In the ever-evolving world of makeup, finding the perfect eyebrow product can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. This is especially true for those with lighter hair colors, who often struggle to find products that don’t look too harsh or unnatural. Enter the Maybelline New York Express Brow 2-in-1 Pencil and Powder in Light Blonde – a dual-ended eyebrow tool that promises to deliver natural-looking, perfectly defined brows with minimal effort.
As a makeup artist with years of experience working with clients of all ages and coloring, I’ve tested countless eyebrow products across all price points. Today, I’m taking a deep dive into this affordable drugstore option to determine if it deserves a place in your makeup bag.
Product Specifications
- Brand: Maybelline New York
- Product Name: Express Brow 2-in-1 Pencil and Powder
- Color: Light Blonde
- Size: 0.02 Fluid Ounces
- Format: Dual-ended pencil with powder applicator
- Price Point: Budget-friendly (typically under $10)
Design and Packaging
The Maybelline Express Brow 2-in-1 comes in a slim, portable package typical of drugstore eyebrow products. The dual-ended design features a twist-up pencil on one end and a sponge-tipped powder applicator on the other. This 2-in-1 approach eliminates the need to carry multiple products, making it ideal for on-the-go touch-ups or travel.
The pencil end features a unique triangular shape that differs from traditional round eyebrow pencils. This design is intended to mimic the natural shape and arch of the eyebrow, allowing for more precise application. The pencil advances with a twist mechanism (no sharpening required), while the powder end has a retractable sponge applicator that dispenses the powder product.
The packaging is functional rather than fancy – it won’t win any beauty awards for aesthetics, but it serves its purpose effectively. The cap clicks securely into place on both ends, protecting the product when not in use.
Formula and Texture
Pencil End
The pencil portion of this product has a firmer texture than typical eyeliner pencils, which is actually advantageous for eyebrow application. The firmer consistency allows for better control and prevents that heavy-handed, drawn-on look that can make brows appear artificial. The triangular tip is designed to create hair-like strokes when used with light pressure.
Many reviewers note that the pencil has a drier texture compared to some higher-end products. While this can initially seem like a drawback, it actually helps the product stay in place throughout the day without smudging. The color deposits gradually, allowing for buildable coverage – a particularly important feature for those with lighter hair who want subtle definition without overwhelming their natural coloring.
Powder End
The powder end features a tapered foam applicator that dispenses a fine powder. The powder has a soft, velvety texture that adheres well to both skin and hair. It’s designed to fill in sparse areas quickly and create a softer, more diffused look than the pencil alone can achieve.
Some users report confusion about how to use the powder applicator, noting that it doesn’t always dispense product evenly. The mechanism works by twisting the base to push powder onto the sponge tip, but it can take a few uses to get the hang of it.
Color Analysis: Light Blonde
The Light Blonde shade is designed for those with blonde, light brown, or even graying hair. However, color perception varies widely among users, with some finding it perfect for their blonde brows and others describing it as more of a light taupe or soft brown.
After analyzing numerous reviews, here’s what I’ve found about the Light Blonde shade:
- It’s one of the few drugstore “blonde” shades that doesn’t pull orange or red (a common complaint with many blonde eyebrow products)
- It has a neutral to slightly cool undertone, making it suitable for true blondes and those with ashy blonde hair
- The color appears more natural when applied lightly and built up gradually
- Some extremely fair users find it slightly too dark, while others with darker blonde or light brown hair find it perfect
- The shade works surprisingly well for those with graying or white brows who want a subtle definition without harsh contrast
One particularly interesting observation from a reviewer with extremely fair coloring: “The color is truly LIGHT blonde and doesn’t look out of place on me, but I also go easy on the application. The color seems buildable if you wanted something a little darker.”
However, another reviewer noted: “This is a nice eyebrow pencil, but it is more of a light brown color, not blonde as the title and picture show. There is no blonde anywhere in the color.”
This discrepancy in perception likely comes down to individual coloring, application technique, and personal expectations.
Application and Ease of Use
The dual-ended design of this product offers flexibility in application techniques. Based on user experiences, here are the most effective methods for applying this product:
Method 1: Powder First, Then Pencil
While the instructions reportedly suggest using the pencil first, many users find better results by reversing this order:
- Use the powder end to create a base and fill in larger areas
- Follow with the pencil to define edges and fill in any remaining sparse spots
As one experienced user explained: “I use the powder end first (which as an eyeshadow is not that dark), then go over the outside corners with the pencil end for more depth.”
Method 2: Pencil First, Then Powder
This is the manufacturer’s recommended approach:
- Use the pencil to outline and shape the brow
- Apply the powder to fill in and create a softer, more natural appearance
Method 3: Using Each End Independently
Many users report using just one end of the product depending on their needs:
- The powder end alone for a softer, more natural look
- The pencil end alone for more definition and precision
The triangular shape of the pencil requires a bit of experimentation to determine which angle works best for different parts of the brow. As one reviewer noted: “The triangular point of the Maybelline pencil is strange, but lends itself to lightly drawing strokes that follow your other brow hairs–though I’m not quite sure which end of the triangle I’m supposed to be using where.”
For best results, most users recommend:
- Using light, feathery strokes with the pencil
- Following the natural direction of hair growth
- Blending with a spoolie brush after application (not included with the product)
- Building color gradually, especially for those with lighter coloring
Performance and Longevity
Staying Power
The longevity of this product receives mixed reviews, though most users find it satisfactory for the price point. The consensus seems to be that it lasts throughout a standard workday but may require touch-ups after extended wear or in hot/humid conditions.
Several reviewers specifically mention that it holds up well during normal daily activities:
- “It stays ALL DAY.”
- “This lasts me forever and it stays on all day and night.”
- “It stays on all day. Easy to apply. Doesn’t smudge.”
While it’s not marketed as waterproof, some users report decent water resistance: “It is not waterproof but has lasted trips to the lake.” Others note that it will come off with excessive sweating: “It will come off if you wipe sweat from you brow a lot, but, just a little to normal amount, it stays on just fine.”
Wear Experience
The product wears comfortably throughout the day, with no reports of irritation, even from users with sensitive skin. One 67-year-old reviewer specifically noted: “My older skin is easily irritated, so that I’d have red itchy eyes from various products. I’ve had no reaction when using these eyebrow duos, so for me they are hypo-allergenic.”
Several users mention that the product doesn’t flake or fade patchily throughout the day, maintaining a consistent appearance from application to removal.
Durability and Value
The durability of the physical product receives mixed feedback. Some users report issues with the pencil breaking easily if extended too far, while others praise its sturdiness compared to similar products.
As for product longevity, most users find that one pencil lasts between 2-3 months with daily use, though many note that the pencil side typically runs out before the powder side. As one user explained: “The pencil part does seem to get used up faster than others, lasting a few months with daily use. But still better than the others I’ve tried.”
In terms of value, the consensus is strongly positive. Many reviewers specifically mention trying more expensive products and returning to this one:
- “I’ve bought a LOT of eyebrow pencils in my lifetime (88 yrs) and for the money this is one of the best. Most of the ones I bought were 2 to 3 times this price and didn’t begin to measure up to this Maybelline product.”
- “This eyebrow pencil is economically superior to most others, and I love the way the color looks— Totally natural.”
Versatility
An interesting finding from several reviews is that this product is quite versatile beyond its intended use as an eyebrow product. Multiple users report successfully using it as an eyeliner:
“I use these not just as eyebrow pencils but also as eyeliners, both right over the top lashes and right under the lower lashes. They are the best eyeliners I’ve ever used, especially the powder end, which goes on super smoothly.”
This dual functionality adds significant value for those looking to streamline their makeup collection or for travel purposes.
Who Is This Product Best For?
Based on the accumulated feedback, this product appears to work best for:
- Those with lighter hair colors: Particularly those with blonde, light brown, or graying hair who struggle to find shades that aren’t too dark or warm-toned
- Makeup beginners: The buildable formula and dual-ended design make it forgiving and versatile for those still mastering brow techniques
- Mature users: Many reviewers in their 60s, 70s, and beyond specifically mention this product working well for their thinning or graying brows
- Budget-conscious consumers: Those looking for quality performance without a premium price tag
- People with sparse or thinning brows: The combination of pencil precision and powder filling capabilities makes it ideal for addressing brow gaps
One 38-year-old self-described makeup novice perfectly captures the appeal for beginners: “I am 38 but still have the makeup skills of a 10 year old…The price, color, blendability and fool-proof application make this pencil a winner in my book.”
Similarly, an 88-year-old reviewer speaks to its appeal for mature users: “I’ve bought a LOT of eyebrow pencils in my lifetime (88 yrs) and for the money this is one of the best.”
Who Should Look Elsewhere?
This product may not be ideal for:
- Those seeking intense definition: The formula is designed for a more natural look and may not provide enough intensity for bold brow styles
- Very fair/platinum blondes: Some extremely fair users still find the Light Blonde shade too dark
- People who prefer cream-based or gel brow products: The drier texture of both the pencil and powder may not appeal to those who prefer creamier formulations
- Those looking for precise, hair-like strokes: While the pencil can create decent hair-like strokes, it doesn’t offer the precision of a fine-tipped brow pen
Common Complaints
While the majority of feedback is positive, there are several recurring complaints worth noting:
- Powder applicator issues: Some users report difficulty getting the powder to dispense evenly or the sponge applicator falling out before the powder is used up
- Pencil breakage: The pencil can break if extended too far or if too much pressure is applied
- Color mismatch expectations: The “Light Blonde” shade is perceived differently by different users, with some finding it more taupe or light brown than truly blonde
- Longevity of product: Some users wish the pencil side lasted longer, noting it runs out more quickly than the powder side
Comparison to Similar Products
Many reviewers explicitly compare this product to other eyebrow options they’ve tried:
- Compared to high-end alternatives: Multiple users mention trying products from Benefit, Dior, and other premium brands before returning to this more affordable option
- Compared to L’Oréal Paris Brow Stylist: Some users who tried both found the L’Oréal Kabuki crayon faster to apply but the Maybelline offering better for precision
- Compared to Maybelline’s other brow products: Several users mentioned trying Maybelline’s Brow Drama or Tattoo Brow but preferring this classic formula
Tips and Tricks from Experienced Users
Longtime users of this product offer several helpful tips:
- For natural-looking application: “Use the crayon first to outline the brow and lightly fill in and then twist the other end to apply the powder to the attached sponge tip. Then brush it lightly over the brows.”
- To avoid breakage: “Be gentle with pencil side like any drug store kind of product you can break it off if you’re pressing too hard or rolled it up too much.”
- For blending: “It is easily blended with a ‘spoolie’ type brush that I happened to have on hand, but a child’s toothbrush could do the job too.”
- For those finding the color too dark: “I go easy on the application. The color seems buildable if you wanted something a little darker.”
- For color longevity: One dedicated user even shared an advanced tip for those with fading color: “I bought a ColorSilk brown… Took 1/2 tsp of cream and put in a small dish and then added 1/2 tsp of the color. I purposely did not wash my morning face. Stirred the two to blend and then using a Q-Tip brushed in over my eyebrows very carefully.”
Interesting Innovation Note
Several long-term users mention that Maybelline recently changed the shape of the pencil: “Recently the pencil shape changed but, it only made it easier to use & harder to break.” This suggests the company is actively improving the product based on consumer feedback.
Final Verdict
The Maybelline New York Express Brow 2-in-1 Pencil and Powder in Light Blonde offers impressive performance for its modest price point. Its greatest strengths lie in its natural-looking finish, dual functionality, and suitability for lighter hair colors – an often underserved segment of the market.
While it’s not without flaws – namely the occasional issues with the powder applicator mechanism and pencil durability – the overwhelming consensus is that these drawbacks are minor considering the quality-to-price ratio.
Ratings Breakdown (Out of 5)
- Ease of Use: 4.2
- Color Match (Light Blonde): 4.0
- Longevity/Staying Power: 3.8
- Packaging/Design: 3.5
- Value for Money: 4.7
- Overall Performance: 4.2
For those seeking an affordable, versatile eyebrow product that delivers natural-looking results without breaking the bank, the Maybelline Express Brow 2-in-1 Pencil and Powder deserves serious consideration – particularly for those with lighter coloring who struggle to find their perfect match in the drugstore aisle.
As one devoted user perfectly summarized: “Every time I try something new I always come back to the simplicity of these eyebrow sticks.” Perhaps the highest praise a beauty product can receive is this kind of enduring loyalty in an industry driven by constant innovation and new releases.
Whether you’re a makeup novice looking for a foolproof eyebrow solution, a mature user addressing changing brow needs, or simply a savvy consumer who knows a good value when you see one, this Maybelline staple might just become your new go-to for achieving naturally defined brows with minimal effort and maximum impact.
Buy on Amazon: Here
