As a beauty expert, I’ve analyzed the feedback on Maybelline’s iconic Great Lash Washable Mascara in Brownish Black to provide you with a detailed assessment of this classic product. This review synthesizes user experiences to give you a complete picture of what to expect.
Product Overview
Maybelline’s Great Lash has maintained its status as one of America’s most recognizable mascaras for decades. The bright pink and green packaging is instantly identifiable in any makeup collection. This particular offering comes as a 2-count package in the Brownish Black shade, which provides a softer alternative to traditional black mascara.
Formula Performance
Consistency
The formula appears to vary in consistency according to user feedback. While many long-term users praise its reliability, some recent purchasers note that the formula seems thinner than previous versions, suggesting potential formula changes over time. The washable nature of this mascara is frequently highlighted as a significant benefit, making removal straightforward without harsh makeup removers.
Longevity
When fresh, the mascara applies smoothly and maintains its appearance throughout wear. However, some users reported receiving dried-up or flaking product, indicating potential quality control issues or stock rotation problems from certain sellers.
Eye Sensitivity Compatibility
For those with sensitive eyes, this mascara presents mixed results. Several users specifically mentioned that Great Lash works well for their sensitive eyes, with one noting it doesn’t cause irritation. However, at least one user experienced burning and dryness, suggesting that individual sensitivity responses vary considerably.
Application Experience
The Wand
The wand design generates divided opinions. Some users appreciate its small size, finding it provides precision and ease of use, particularly for those with vision difficulties. The slim wand allows for controlled application and reaching smaller lashes. However, others find the wand too small for efficient application, indicating personal preference plays a significant role in satisfaction with this feature.
Application Tips
One practical tip mentioned is to wipe excess product from the wand before application to prevent clumping. This simple step appears to improve the application experience significantly.
Value Proposition
At its typically affordable price point, Great Lash represents good value for many users, especially when purchased in a two-pack. Several reviewers specifically mentioned the competitive pricing compared to retail stores, enhancing the overall value perception.
Consistency Across Time
A recurring theme in the feedback suggests possible changes to the product over time. Long-term users note differences in the current formula or applicator compared to their previous experiences. This indicates either formula adjustments by Maybelline or inconsistencies in production.
Who This Mascara Works Best For
Based on the collective feedback, this mascara appears best suited for:
- Those seeking a natural, everyday mascara rather than dramatic volume
- Users who prioritize easy removal at the end of the day
- People who prefer more control with a smaller wand
- Individuals looking for a softer alternative to pure black mascara
- Budget-conscious consumers who want reliable performance at an affordable price
The Brownish Black shade offers a particularly good option for those with lighter coloring or who prefer a less intense look than traditional black mascara provides.
Potential Drawbacks
Several issues emerged from the feedback that prospective buyers should consider:
- Inconsistent product quality (some reporting dried-up product upon arrival)
- Possible reactions for those with extremely sensitive eyes
- A smaller wand that may not suit everyone’s application preferences
- Potential thinning of the formula compared to earlier versions
The Legacy Factor
Great Lash has maintained its position in the beauty industry for decades, creating a sense of reliability and nostalgia. Multiple reviewers mentioned using the product for years, demonstrating brand loyalty that speaks to its consistent performance. One reviewer even called it the “Greatest classic mascara,” acknowledging its iconic status.
Shipping and Fulfillment
Most users reported satisfactory delivery experiences, with packages arriving on time or even earlier than expected. This suggests reliable fulfillment, though the few mentions of dried-up product indicate that storage or inventory management might occasionally affect product quality.
Comparative Context
Within the drugstore mascara category, Great Lash continues to hold its ground despite increasing competition. Its recognizable packaging and long-standing reputation help maintain its relevance, though user feedback suggests that innovation from competitors may be creating higher expectations that challenge Great Lash’s traditional formulation.
Conclusion
Maybelline New York Great Lash Washable Mascara in Brownish Black remains a reliable, budget-friendly option in the competitive mascara market. Its greatest strengths lie in its easy removal, gentle formula suitable for many with sensitive eyes, and the precision offered by its smaller wand.
However, potential inconsistencies in product quality and the divisive nature of its applicator design mean that not all users will have the same positive experience. Those seeking dramatic, voluminous lashes may find this classic formula too subtle for their preferences.
For longtime users, the possible formula changes noted by some reviewers might affect their satisfaction, though many continue to purchase this product repeatedly, suggesting that its fundamental appeal remains intact.
Overall, Great Lash continues to earn its place in many makeup collections, particularly for those who appreciate its natural finish, washable formula, and the softness of the Brownish Black shade for everyday wear.
Buy on Amazon: Here
