As a beauty expert with years of experience testing and reviewing makeup products, I’ve seen countless eyebrow products come and go. The Maybelline New York Brow Precise Shaping Eyebrow Pencil in Soft Brown has remained a staple in many makeup collections for good reason. In this comprehensive review, I’ll analyze what makes this affordable drugstore option so popular while also addressing its limitations based on extensive consumer feedback and personal expertise.
- Product Name: Maybelline New York Brow Precise Shaping Eyebrow Pencil
- Shade: Soft Brown
- Weight: 0.02 oz
- Features: Dual-ended with pencil and spoolie brush
- Price Point: Budget-friendly drugstore option
First Impressions and Packaging
The Maybelline Brow Precise Shaping Eyebrow Pencil comes in Maybelline’s signature green packaging, though several consumers noted issues with the packaging itself. Multiple reviewers mentioned difficulty opening the shrink wrap, with some stating it required a razor blade to open, which is certainly concerning from a user experience perspective.
The pencil features a dual-ended design with the actual pencil on one end and a spoolie brush on the other—a standard but practical configuration for an eyebrow product. Some users noted that the cap on the brush end tends to fall off easily, which could lead to damage when carried in a makeup bag.
Application Experience
Texture and Consistency
The pencil’s texture is one of its most discussed features across reviews. Many users describe it as “soft” and praise how easily it glides onto the brows. This softness makes it particularly suited for those with sparse or thinning brows, as one long-term user with “extremely thin, hardly visible eyebrows” noted.
However, this softness is also frequently cited as a drawback. The pencil’s consistency means it requires frequent sharpening as the tip wears down quickly. Several reviewers mentioned breakage issues, with one stating it “breaks with the softest touch,” resulting in product waste. Another reviewer described it as “waxy,” which affected application.
The ideal application technique seems to involve gentle, light strokes rather than applying pressure, as pressing too hard can result in uneven application or breakage. As one user with five years of experience using the product advised: “It’s soft, so you need to be careful not to press too hard and use gentle strokes or you’ll end up with an uneven coating.”
Ease of Application
For those who master the light touch required, the pencil offers remarkably easy application. Many reviewers praised how smoothly it applies, with comments like “glides on nicely” and “goes on smoothly” appearing frequently. The product seems particularly beloved by older women or those with sparse brows who appreciate how easily it creates the appearance of fuller brows.
The included spoolie brush receives almost universal praise, with even critics of the pencil itself often complimenting the brush’s quality. It serves its intended purpose of blending and softening the pencil strokes perfectly, creating a more natural look. As one reviewer shared: “The brush on the other end really helps smooth it over and even out all the color.”
Color Payoff and Shade Range
This review focuses specifically on the Soft Brown shade, which received mixed feedback regarding its color accuracy. While many found it to be a perfect match for light to medium brown hair, others felt it was darker than expected for a “soft brown.” One reviewer explicitly stated it was “dark brown” rather than soft brown.
The color intensity can be adjusted somewhat by varying the pressure applied during application, with lighter pressure resulting in a softer color. This versatility is appreciated by users who need to match their natural brow color: “With more or less pressure it goes on lighter and darker, so you can make it work easier than if you are using a gel.”
Performance and Longevity
Staying Power
The longevity of this eyebrow pencil varies significantly across reviews, suggesting that individual skin type and environmental conditions play a major role in its staying power. Some users report impressive durability, with one long-term user stating: “It stays on with sweat and swimming! When I’ve exited the pool hours after splashing my face and diving underwater, it was still there.”
Others experienced disappointing wear time, with comments like “it didn’t seem to stay on” and “seems to melt off my face quickly.” This inconsistency could be attributed to differences in skin type (oily vs. dry), climate conditions, or application technique.
For those seeking maximum longevity, one reviewer offered this useful tip: “I brush my brows, apply this, then use a clear mascara to go over my brows and the color is set and looks very natural.”
Smudging and Transfer
Smudging appears to be a common issue with this pencil. Multiple reviewers noted that it “easily smudges” throughout the day. This is likely related to its soft, somewhat waxy texture. Those with oily skin or those in humid environments might experience more smudging issues than others.
Product Lifespan
The lifespan of each pencil varies depending on usage frequency and application technique. Based on the reviews, with daily use, a single pencil typically lasts between 1-4 months. One reviewer stated that “one pencil will last me around four months with near daily use,” while another mentioned going through “a pencil every four to five weeks.”
The frequent sharpening required due to the soft consistency likely contributes to faster product consumption for some users.
Natural Appearance
Perhaps the most consistent praise across positive reviews is for the natural-looking results this pencil delivers. Many long-term users specifically cite the natural appearance as their reason for brand loyalty, with comments like:
- “No one knows I draw them on. It is very soft looking.”
- “The brown color is soft and natural looking. I don’t look hard and being an older woman I like that.”
- “It’s the only one I’ve ever found that… helps me to define my brows.”
This natural finish is particularly valued by older consumers whose brows have thinned with age. The combination of the soft pencil and the blending brush allows for building color gradually, avoiding the harsh, drawn-on look that can occur with stiffer or more pigmented products.
Value and Price Point
As a drugstore product, the Maybelline Brow Precise offers good value for its price point. Several reviewers specifically mentioned the “reasonable price” as a selling point. However, some felt that the frequent replacement requirement (due to breakage or rapid use) affected its overall value proposition.
When purchased from retail stores, the price seems to meet expectations for a drugstore brand. A few reviewers noted finding better prices online than in local stores, though this would need to be balanced against the potential packaging and product quality issues some online purchasers reported.
Potential Drawbacks and Limitations
Quality Control Issues
A concerning number of reviewers reported receiving products that appeared used or damaged:
- “Pencil arrived with NO CAP, and has fibers on the tip as if it was already used.”
- “It just had sticky wrapped around it saying what it was. It appears to be a used product.”
- “The box was opened when I received the order.”
- “The package was falling apart and the pencil was smashed in half.”
These reports suggest possible quality control issues, particularly with online ordering. Several reviewers also questioned whether the product they received was authentic Maybelline, with comments like “Completely dupe product. Not actual maybelline.”
Sharpening Difficulties
The soft texture that makes application so easy also creates challenges when sharpening. Multiple reviewers reported breaking issues when attempting to sharpen the pencil:
- “Too soft, it is almost impossible to sharpen it, it breaks every time.”
- “The pencil is so soft it bends when you try to apply it and impossible to sharpen.”
- “It sharpens on a slant.”
These difficulties contribute to product waste and frustration, particularly for long-term users.
Inconsistent Formula
Some long-term users reported a change in the product’s formula, noting that while the name remained the same, the performance differed from previous versions:
- “I’ve been using this product for years as it’s been the only one that creates the natural look I want. Then something happened and it is a completely different product.”
- “It’s not like the original product.”
This suggests possible reformulation that has affected the product’s performance for loyal users.
Ideal Use Cases
Based on the collective feedback, this eyebrow pencil seems best suited for:
- Those with sparse or thinning brows who need to create definition where little exists naturally
- Older consumers who appreciate the natural, soft finish it provides
- Those with dry to normal skin types who may experience less smudging issues
- People seeking a natural brow look rather than a bold, defined brow
- Those new to brow makeup who appreciate the ease of application and included brush
It may be less suitable for:
- Those with oily skin who may experience more smudging and transfer
- People seeking long-lasting wear without touch-ups
- Those wanting a precise, defined brow that stays sharp throughout the day
- Users who prefer low-maintenance products that don’t require frequent sharpening
Comparison to Alternatives
Several reviewers compared this product to alternatives, both within and outside the Maybelline brand:
- Some preferred the Maybelline Expert Wear Eyebrow pencil over this Brow Precise version
- Others noted that newer Maybelline brow products differed from this one, but still preferred the Brow Precise
- A few mentioned trying other brands but returning to this product for its natural finish
The comparison feedback suggests that this pencil occupies a specific niche in the market: softer than many traditional eyebrow pencils but more natural-looking than newer pomade or gel formulations.
Application Tips From Experienced Users
Synthesizing advice from long-term users reveals several practical tips for maximizing this product’s performance:
- Use gentle, light strokes rather than applying pressure
- Set with clear mascara or brow gel for enhanced longevity
- Ensure brows are dry before application for best results
- Use the spoolie brush to blend and soften the color for a more natural look
- Vary pressure to achieve different color intensity
- Store properly to prevent breakage
- Consider using with a brow powder for enhanced definition and staying power
Conclusion
The Maybelline New York Brow Precise Shaping Eyebrow Pencil in Soft Brown elicits passionate responses from users, both positive and negative. Its soft texture and natural finish have earned it loyal fans, particularly among those with sparse brows seeking a natural-looking solution. However, issues with longevity, smudging, and breakage prevent it from being a universal recommendation.
For the price point, it offers good value when it works for a consumer’s specific needs and skin type. The dual-ended design with a quality spoolie brush enhances its utility, and the smooth application makes it accessible even for makeup beginners.
Those considering this product should weigh their priorities: if natural appearance and ease of application are paramount, this pencil may be worth trying despite potential longevity issues. However, those prioritizing long-wear performance or precise definition might be better served by alternative formulations.
After analyzing extensive consumer feedback, I would rate the Maybelline New York Brow Precise Shaping Eyebrow Pencil in Soft Brown 3.5 out of 5 stars – a solid drugstore option with notable strengths and limitations that will perform differently depending on individual needs and preferences.
Final Rating: ★★★½☆
Pros:
- Smooth, easy application
- Natural-looking results
- Quality spoolie brush for blending
- Affordable price point
- Works well for sparse or thinning brows
- Buildable color
Cons:
- Requires frequent sharpening
- Prone to breakage
- Inconsistent staying power
- Potential packaging issues
- May smudge on oily skin
- Some quality control concerns
Buy on Amazon: Here
