As a makeup expert with years of experience evaluating cosmetics across all price points, I’m excited to share my in-depth review of Maybelline’s Electric Orange lipstick from their Color Sensational Vivids line. This vibrant shade has generated quite mixed reactions from consumers, and I’ll help you understand if it might be right for you.
Maybelline’s Color Sensational Vivids Lipcolor in Electric Orange is a bold, statement-making lipstick that promises vibrant color with a creamy finish. Part of Maybelline’s affordable drugstore line, it aims to deliver runway-worthy colors at an accessible price point.
Color & Pigmentation
The Electric Orange shade lives up to its name – it’s an intensely bright, true orange that makes an immediate impact. Based on customer feedback, this is a polarizing aspect of the product:
- Some users find it “true to years of using the product,” suggesting consistent color payoff
- Others describe it as “somewhat too orangey” and “similar to orange crayon”
- One Spanish-speaking reviewer noted a discrepancy between the color shown in photos and the actual product
The pigmentation appears to be strong, with one user even comparing its staying power to a matte formula despite its creamy consistency: “A SMALL KISS, MAYBE, BUT THE ORANGE CREAMY LIPSTICK STAYS ON LIKE IT’S A MATTE.
However, another reviewer found that “the color was not bright or transparent on my lips,” suggesting possible variation in how it applies on different skin tones and lip pigmentation.
Texture & Finish
The texture of this lipstick seems to be divisive:
- It has a creamy consistency that some appreciate
- One reviewer describes it as “too oily”
- Several mention it’s “not very moisturizing” despite its creamy appearance
- Another reviewer compares it to a “labial hidratante con color” (tinted lip balm)
An interesting application tip comes from an 86-year-old redhead who shares: “I dab a little concealer on lips then apply lipstick. It softens the orange a little bit.” This technique helps temper the intense orange while maintaining the vibrant quality.
Longevity & Wear
The staying power receives mixed reviews:
- One user enthusiastically notes it “STAYS ON LIKE IT’S A MATTE”
- Another states it “se quita” (comes off easily), suggesting poor longevity
- A positive note is that it “didn’t cause lips to dry out” during wear
Sensory Experience
Several reviewers mentioned sensory aspects beyond color and texture:
- “There is also a subtle smell”
- One concerning comment: “It also feels as if there is a metal in the lipstick. It will make your lips feel weird.”
This metallic sensation could be related to certain ingredients in the formula that create a slight tingling or cooling effect, which some people may find uncomfortable.
Versatility & Occasions
Electric Orange proves to be surprisingly versatile:
- Perfect for making a bold statement in everyday wear for those comfortable with vibrant colors
- One reviewer mentioned it “works great for our haunted house characters,” highlighting its potential for costume and theatrical applications
- Another was specifically seeking this color out again after having used it before, suggesting it has devoted fans
Suitability By Skin Tone & Age
The feedback suggests this shade may not be universally flattering:
- One reviewer noted it was “not flattering for my skin tone”
- However, the 86-year-old redhead found a way to make it work with her coloring using the concealer trick
This indicates Electric Orange might be particularly striking on those with warmer undertones or those who know how to adjust the application to complement their specific coloring.
Availability
A practical note from several reviewers is that this specific shade can be difficult to find in physical stores, making online purchasing necessary for those who have become devoted to the color.
Value Proposition
Maybelline is known for offering affordable cosmetics, and this lipstick represents good value if:
- You’re looking for a truly vibrant orange statement lip
- You’re comfortable with a creamy (possibly slightly oily) formula
- You don’t require extreme moisturizing properties
- The potential metallic sensation doesn’t bother you
Final Verdict
Maybelline’s Color Sensational Vivids Lipcolor in Electric Orange is a bold, high-impact orange lipstick that delivers on its promise of vibrant color. It works wonderfully for those seeking a statement lip or special applications like theatrical makeup. The formula offers decent staying power for a creamy lipstick, though it may not be as moisturizing as some would prefer.
This is definitely not a “play it safe” shade – it’s for makeup enthusiasts who want to make a statement or those with specific creative applications in mind. The application tip from the 86-year-old reviewer (using concealer underneath) offers a clever way to tone down the intensity for those who find the straight application too bold.
For the price point, this Maybelline offering delivers impressive color payoff and reasonable performance, despite some consistency and sensory concerns noted by a few users. If you’re curious about trying a true orange lipstick without a significant investment, this could be an excellent option to experiment with this daring color trend.
Remember that with such a bold shade, complementary makeup should be kept relatively simple to let the lips be the focal point of your look. Pair with neutral eyes, defined brows, and clean skin for a modern, fashion-forward appearance.
Buy on Amazon: Here
