As a beauty expert with years in the industry, I’m always on the lookout for products that deliver both effectiveness and value for my clients. Maybelline New York—a brand that has stood the test of time—has created a classic with their Cover Stick Corrector Concealer. In this review, I’ll focus specifically on the Deep Beige shade, a popular choice across various skin tones.
In this comprehensive assessment, I’ll analyze the product based on multiple aspects: coverage capability, staying power, versatility, value for money, and both the strengths and weaknesses reported by consumers. Let’s dive into why this product has remained a favorite for many throughout the years.
Product Basics
The Maybelline New York Cover Stick Corrector Concealer is a solid stick concealer designed to cover imperfections such as dark circles, brown spots, blemishes, and discolorations. The stick format provides convenience and ease of use, particularly when precision coverage of small facial areas is needed.
The Deep Beige shade is a medium to deep tone ideally suited for a range of skin types. However, through analyzing reviews, there appears to be some variance in the perception of this shade’s depth—a point I’ll discuss in more detail in later sections.
Coverage and Performance
Coverage Capability
One of the most notable characteristics of the Cover Stick Concealer is its exceptional coverage. Many users have commented that the product “covers imperfections better than any other on the market.” This is considerable praise for a product at a drugstore price point.
The product particularly excels at concealing dark under-eye circles. One user shared: “Great coverage, counteracts my dark circles.” This isn’t surprising, as the thick consistency of the product is specifically designed to provide high coverage.
Notably, some users have employed this product for purposes beyond conventional makeup. One specific review mentions: “My husband uses it to cover his purpora on his hands and arms — does the trick better than anything else.” This illustrates the versatility of the product for various coverage needs.
Another user reports: “This product covers unhealed sores. I use it every day.” This is a strong testament to the high coverage capability of the product, though I would advise caution when applying cosmetics to open wounds.
Longevity and Staying Power
Regarding longevity, the Cover Stick Concealer receives fairly positive feedback. Many users report that the product holds up well throughout the day. One user shares: “I can wear this stuff all day long at work, then workout hard at the gym and it’s still right where I put it. I don’t even have to touch it up.”
However, there are also some contrasting reviews about staying power. One user reports: “IT STARTS TO RUN AFTER A FEW HOURS. HAVE TO REAPPLY. IF NOT RIGHT ON TOP OF IT, IT CLUMPS UP IN CORNER OF THE EYE.” This suggests that differences in experience may relate to skin type, environmental conditions, or application method.
A helpful tip from a longtime user: “Then I put loose face power over all of my face for a finished look. The powder also keeps it from wiping off if my eyes water.” This is valuable advice for enhancing the product’s durability.
Blendability and Texture
For blendability, feedback is mixed but leans positive. Many users report that the product blends well and has an appropriate texture. “Easy to apply blends with my skin and looks natural,” one review stated.
Another user describes their application process: “It goes on from the tube, and I use my finger to smooth it out and blend in. Then I put loose face power over all of my face for a finished look.” This indicates the product can be easily integrated into daily makeup routines.
However, some users report issues with texture. One comment mentions: “A little drying so had to add lotion when using.” Others describe it as “Ok a little ashy” for their skin tone. And some users find it “Kind of chalky and doesn’t blend all that well” or “Pasty, over shadowed foundation especially around the eyes.”
Color Range and Shade Selection
A prominent theme in the reviews is the variance in perception of the Deep Beige shade. This is an important point to note for those interested in this color.
Some users find the shade too light: “Item description said it is ‘deep beige’ but it is actually a very, very light beige, so it is totally useless to me.” Another commented: “You need darker colors, this is too light for me.”
Conversely, some users find it suitable: “I’m pretty pale and this color was spot on to my skin. Nice coverage.” Another user stated: “Better than the other colors I’ve tried; this one comes much closer to the color of my skin…the ‘fair’ colors were almost ashen white.”
Particularly interesting is a review from a user who purchased Deep Beige with different expectations: “For reference my skin is MAC Nc13 or FitMe 110. I bought this concealer in ‘deep beige’ thinking it would be a deep enough color to use for a subtle contour. It is actually very light and very yellow, unlike the picture.”
One user offers an insightful comment about concealer shade selection: “Contrary to popular belief you should not match the concealer to your skin color. You should go 2-3 shades darker, when you’re using it to cover the under eye area.”
Maybelline also offers corrector shades like yellow and green, which are mentioned in reviews. One user explains: “You can also use yellow which cancels out black (for those under eye bags) and green cancels out red (for example, if you have a rudy complexion or red blemishes).”
Value and Price Point
A major advantage of the Cover Stick Concealer is its affordability. Many users mention the low price as a significant plus. “I’ve used this for years and hard to find in stores. Good price too,” one review noted.
Another user compares it to more expensive products: “I have purchased much more expensive products but find this one works just as well!” This emphasizes that this product provides good value for money.
One fairly summarizing review states it as: “Covers well. No complaints.” This simplicity and effectiveness, combined with the affordable price, has made this product a staple in many makeup collections.
Longevity and Long-term Reliability
A standout point from the reviews is the long-term reliability of the product. Many users have remained loyal to the Cover Stick Concealer for years, even decades.
“I’ve used this product for over 20 years,” one user shares. Another writes: “I am 63 and I have used this product since I was a teenager.” These testimonials are evidence of the product’s reliability and effectiveness over time.
A concern, however, is that some users report the product arriving broken. “I was very disappointed when I opened up my makeup the whole thing fell apart,” one review noted. Another mentions: “Just now opened the first concealer stick and found it to not be secured to the tube. Very hard to apply when it wobbles in the tube.” This suggests there may be quality control or shipping issues with some orders.
Application Methods and Tips
The reviews provide multiple insights into how users apply the Cover Stick Concealer. One long-time user describes their process: “I just take the crayon stick and put it in a V pattern at the bridge of my nose area with The V wings that go above the eyebrows and then I put it in a full circle up and lower lid on the eye area and then I put it in the creases of my laugh lines, and one line clear underneath my chin from corner of the jawbone to the jawbone on the other side so that I can remove any shadows, so my face looks flawless, but virtually untouched.”
A common tip is to use powder to set the product: “Then I put loose face power over all of my face for a finished look. The powder also keeps it from wiping off if my eyes water.”
Another user mentions using the product with castor oil: “Now I like to put a little bit of organic castor oil underneath which makes the makeup look better.” This is an interesting tip for those with drier skin.
Overall Assessment and Conclusion
After thoroughly analyzing the reviews of the Maybelline New York Cover Stick Corrector Concealer in Deep Beige, I can conclude that it’s a worthy product with an affordable price tag. It provides good coverage, is easy to use, and has a long history of reliability.
Strengths:
- Superior coverage for dark circles and blemishes
- Affordable price point
- Convenient stick format
- Easy to apply and blend for many users
- Good staying power, especially when set with powder
- Can be used for various purposes
Weaknesses:
- Inconsistency with the Deep Beige shade – some find it too light, some find it suitable
- Reports of product arriving broken
- Some users find the texture a bit dry or difficult to blend
- May run or clump for some users
Who Should Use This Product:
- Those seeking a concealer with medium to high coverage
- Those on a limited budget but wanting an effective product
- Those who prefer a stick format for easy application
- Those with medium to oily skin (those with dry skin may need to hydrate first)
Who Might Want to Avoid:
- Those with deeper skin tones, as Deep Beige may be lighter than expected
- Those who prefer a more moisturizing or liquid texture
- Those needing a concealer that requires no touch-ups throughout the day
Expert Recommendations
Based on my analysis of the reviews and my professional expertise, here are some tips to get the most out of the Maybelline Cover Stick Concealer:
- Prep the skin first: If you have dry skin, apply a thin layer of moisturizer beforehand to prevent the product from drying out. A drop of organic castor oil can also be effective as one user suggested.
- Application technique: Apply directly from the stick for areas needing concentrated coverage, then use a finger or makeup sponge to blend the edges. The warmth from your finger can help the product melt slightly into the skin.
- Powder setting: Always set the concealer with powder to increase longevity. Many users reported this as key to preventing the product from moving.
- Combine with corrector shades: Consider using yellow concealer under Deep Beige to neutralize blue-purple under-eye circles, or green concealer under Deep Beige to neutralize red areas.
- Shade selection: As one user suggested, don’t be afraid to use a shade darker than your skin tone, particularly for under-eye areas. This can provide a better brightening and covering effect.
Maybelline’s Cover Stick Concealer is an excellent example of how an affordably priced product can deliver reliable performance compared to more expensive competitors. Its longevity in the market and customer loyalty over decades is a testament to its effectiveness. While it may not be the perfect choice for every skin type or coverage need, it certainly deserves a place in your makeup collection, especially if you value good bang for your buck and dependable coverage.
Buy on Amazon: Here
