As a beauty expert with years of experience testing countless concealers across all price points, I’ve had the opportunity to thoroughly evaluate the Maybelline New York Dream Brightening Creamy Concealer in Light (0.11 oz). This affordable drugstore option has developed quite a following, but does it truly deliver on its promises? After analyzing numerous consumer experiences and testing it myself, here’s my in-depth assessment.
First Impressions & Packaging
The Maybelline Dream Brightening Creamy Concealer comes in a convenient stick format that resembles a crayon or pencil. This design offers excellent portability and precision, making it ideal for on-the-go touch-ups. At just 0.11 oz, it’s compact enough to slip into even the smallest makeup bag.
The packaging is practical rather than luxurious, which is expected at this price point. Some users reported issues with the cap coming loose in their purses, potentially creating messes. A few also mentioned that the small sponge at the tip can fall off if pressed too hard during application.
Texture & Consistency
The product’s name suggests a creamy formula, and for many users, it delivers on this promise. The consistency is generally described as smooth and creamy, gliding onto the skin without excessive tugging. However, experiences varied significantly:
- Many users praised its creaminess, noting it applied effortlessly and blended well with either fingers or tools
- Some found it surprisingly dry despite the “creamy” descriptor
- A few complained it was “like a crayon” and too stiff, requiring significant warming up before application
- Those with drier under-eye areas particularly appreciated the formula’s moisture
The variance in experience suggests that skin type plays a crucial role in how this concealer performs. Those with combination or normal skin seemed to have the best results, while those with very dry skin sometimes found it too stiff.
Coverage & Finish
The Dream Brightening Concealer offers moderate coverage that can be built up in layers:
- Most users found it provided sufficient coverage for mild to moderate dark circles
- It performed well on facial discoloration and minor blemishes
- Some successfully used it to cover body imperfections like bruises
- A few users with severe dark circles found the coverage inadequate
The finish has a subtle illuminating quality that many users appreciated. It contains fine reflective particles (which some described as “glitter,” though this seems an exaggeration) that help brighten the under-eye area. This feature makes it particularly suited for those looking to counter dullness and fatigue rather than completely mask severe discoloration.
Importantly, several users noted that this is not a full-coverage concealer. Those seeking heavy-duty coverage for significant discoloration might be disappointed.
Shade Range & Color Match
The “Light” shade received mixed feedback regarding its color match:
- Some found it perfect for fair to light skin tones
- Others felt it ran darker than expected for a light shade, describing it as more of a “medium beige”
- A few users with fair skin purchased it as a concealer but found it worked better as a contour due to the darker-than-expected shade
The limited shade range is definitely a drawback. While the “Light” shade works well for many, those at the fairest end of the spectrum might find it too dark, while those with deeper skin tones would need to explore other shade options in the line.
Application & Blendability
The stick format allows for direct application to the skin, which most users found convenient. Application techniques varied among satisfied users:
- Some applied directly from the stick and blended with fingers
- Others preferred using a concealer brush or beauty blender
- Several mentioned applying to fingertips first, then tapping onto the skin
- A few recommended applying over eye cream for the smoothest application
Blendability received generally positive feedback, with most users finding it easy to work with. However, a small number complained that it was difficult to blend seamlessly, especially those who found the texture drier than expected.
Longevity & Wear
Performance throughout the day received mixed reviews:
- Many users reported that it lasted their entire workday without significant fading
- Some noted that it creased after a few hours, particularly on mature skin
- A few mentioned that it disappeared quickly and offered only short-term coverage
- Setting with powder appeared to improve longevity significantly
Using a good eye cream underneath and setting with powder seemed to be key factors in maximizing wear time. Those who incorporated these steps generally reported better longevity.
Special Considerations for Different Skin Types
For Mature Skin
Several users with mature skin mentioned that the product settled into fine lines and wrinkles. This is a common issue with many concealers, but it seems particularly noteworthy with this product. Using an eye primer and applying sparingly may help minimize this effect.
For Dry Skin
Users with dry under-eye areas had polarized experiences. Some found the creaminess perfect for their dryness, while others felt it accentuated dry patches. Proper hydration before application appears crucial for this skin type.
For Oily Skin
Few reviewers specifically mentioned oily skin, but those who did generally had positive experiences with the concealer’s staying power when set with powder.
Value for Money
At a drugstore price point (typically under $10), most users felt the Maybelline Dream Brightening Concealer offered excellent value:
- Several mentioned that it outperformed high-end concealers costing three to four times as much
- The small size (0.11 oz) was noted by some, but most felt it lasted an acceptable amount of time
- The affordable price point made it accessible for daily use and regular replacement
Unexpected Uses
Interestingly, users discovered several alternative uses beyond traditional concealing:
- Some used it as an eyeshadow primer with good results
- Others employed it as a cream highlighter on the high points of the face
- A few mentioned using it to cover body imperfections like bruises or spots
This versatility adds to the product’s value proposition.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Affordable price point
- Convenient stick format for precise application and portability
- Smooth, creamy texture for most users
- Moderate, buildable coverage
- Subtle brightening effect
- Versatile applications beyond concealing
- Generally good staying power when properly set
Cons:
- Inconsistent texture experiences (some found it too dry)
- Limited shade range
- May settle into fine lines and wrinkles on mature skin
- Some packaging issues (loose cap, sponge tip falling off)
- Not suitable for those seeking full coverage
- Some users experienced premature creasing
When to Choose This Concealer
This concealer is likely to work best for:
- Those with light to medium skin tones
- People seeking moderate coverage with a brightening effect
- Makeup minimalists who prefer quick, easy application
- Users with normal to slightly dry under-eye areas
- Those who prioritize affordability and value
It might not be ideal for:
- Those with very fair or deep skin tones
- People seeking full, opaque coverage for severe dark circles
- Those with very mature skin and pronounced lines
- Users with extremely dry under-eye areas
Daily Routine Integration
Many users shared their successful routines incorporating this concealer. A common effective approach was:
- Cleanse and tone the face thoroughly
- Apply a hydrating eye cream and allow it to absorb (5-10 minutes)
- Tap or swipe the concealer under the eyes and on any discoloration
- Blend with fingertips, a small brush, or a damp beauty sponge
- Set immediately with a light dusting of translucent powder
- Follow with a setting spray for extended wear
This routine maximizes the concealer’s performance and longevity while minimizing potential creasing.
The Verdict
The Maybelline New York Dream Brightening Creamy Concealer in Light represents a solid drugstore option for those seeking moderate coverage with a brightening effect. Its performance can vary significantly based on skin type, application technique, and expectations, but when used appropriately, it offers remarkable value.
While it doesn’t compete with high-end, full-coverage concealers for severe discoloration, it more than holds its own for everyday concealing needs. The convenient format, generally creamy texture, and subtle illuminating properties make it particularly suited for busy individuals seeking a quick, effective under-eye solution.
With proper application techniques (hydration, careful blending, and setting), many users found it comparable to products costing significantly more. Its versatility as an eyeshadow primer or subtle highlighter adds to its appeal as a multitasking product in a minimalist makeup collection.
For the price point, the Maybelline Dream Brightening Creamy Concealer deserves consideration, especially for those with normal to slightly dry skin seeking moderate coverage with a brightening effect. Just be prepared to experiment with application techniques to find what works best for your specific skin type and concerns.
Rating: 4 out of 5 stars
This review is based on analysis of consumer experiences and professional assessment, focusing on the Light shade (0.11 oz) of the Maybelline New York Dream Brightening Creamy Concealer.
Buy on Amazon: Here
