As a beauty expert with years of experience testing and reviewing makeup products, I’ve had the opportunity to thoroughly evaluate the Maybelline New York Fit Me! Blush in Deep Rose (0.16 Ounce). This review synthesizes my professional assessment with insights from numerous customer experiences to give you a complete picture of this popular drugstore blush.
Product Overview
Maybelline’s Fit Me! Blush in Deep Rose is a powder blush that comes in a compact case with an included applicator brush. Part of Maybelline’s affordable Fit Me! line, this blush promises a natural-looking flush of color that complements your skin tone. The Deep Rose shade is described as a rich, rosy pink that aims to provide a natural-looking flush.
Packaging and First Impressions
Compact Design
The Fit Me! Blush comes in a small, portable plastic compact that includes a separate compartment for the included brush. The design is practical and travel-friendly, making it easy to slip into even small makeup bags or purses. Several customers specifically mentioned appreciating this space-efficient design.
The Included Brush
The compact includes a small applicator brush, which receives mixed reviews. While some users appreciate having a built-in applicator for touch-ups on the go, many find it too small and stiff for optimal application. For best results, most experienced users recommend using your own full-sized blush brush rather than relying on the included applicator.
Color and Pigmentation
The Deep Rose Shade
Deep Rose is a moderately warm-toned, medium pink with subtle rosy undertones. It’s designed to create a natural flush that mimics the look of naturally rosy cheeks. The color falls somewhere in the middle of the spectrum – not too bright or too muted.
Pigmentation Level
This is where customer experiences diverge significantly, largely based on skin tone:
- Fair to Light Skin Tones: Users with lighter skin typically find the pigmentation level to be ideal. The color shows up well without being overwhelming, allowing for a subtle, buildable application.
- Medium to Deep Skin Tones: Many users with deeper skin tones report difficulty getting the color to show up noticeably. The pigmentation isn’t strong enough to make a significant impact without multiple layers of product.
The consensus suggests that the Deep Rose shade has a somewhat sheer payoff that requires building up for more noticeable color. This makes it forgiving for makeup beginners with fair skin but potentially frustrating for those seeking a more impactful look or those with deeper skin tones.
Application and Blendability
Texture and Feel
The blush has a fine, soft powder texture that feels lightweight on the skin. It’s not overly powdery or chalky, though some users note it can be a bit hard-pressed in the pan, making it difficult to pick up product on a brush at times.
Blendability
One of the most praised aspects of this blush is its excellent blendability. Even when applied heavily, it blends out easily and seamlessly into the skin. This forgiving formula makes it especially suitable for those who are new to using blush or prefer a more natural makeup look.
Several reviewers specifically mentioned how well it blends out even after applying too much product, making it difficult to overdo. This characteristic makes it nearly foolproof for everyday use.
Application Tips
Based on customer experiences, here are some tips for best application:
- Use a fuller, fluffier brush than the one provided for better pickup and application
- You may need to swirl your brush firmly in the product to pick up enough color
- For deeper skin tones, apply in layers, building up to your desired intensity
- The product works well over both liquid and powder foundation
Wear Time and Performance
Longevity
The Fit Me! Blush in Deep Rose offers moderate lasting power. On average, it stays visible for about 6-8 hours before noticeably fading. Some users report needing to reapply for all-day wear, particularly in warm weather or if you have oily skin.
Appearance Throughout the Day
The blush fades gradually rather than patchily, which is a positive quality. Even as it starts to fade, it maintains a natural appearance without oxidizing or changing color significantly throughout the day.
Suitability for Different Skin Types
The formula seems to work well for various skin types:
- Dry Skin: The powder formula doesn’t emphasize dry patches and blends well even on drier skin types
- Oily Skin: While it may fade somewhat faster on oily skin, it doesn’t become patchy or oxidize
- Sensitive Skin: Several users with sensitive skin mention using this blush without irritation, though some reported reactions to the included brush (not the powder itself)
Performance By Skin Tone
Fair to Light Skin
This is where the Deep Rose shade truly excels. Users with fair to light skin consistently report high satisfaction with the color payoff and natural appearance. The shade provides just enough color to enliven the complexion without looking overdone.
Many fair-skinned users particularly appreciate how the color doesn’t look too intense or “clownish,” which can be a common concern with deeper rose-toned blushes.
Medium Skin
Results are mixed for medium skin tones. Some find it gives a subtle but pretty flush, while others need to build up multiple layers to achieve noticeable color. The sheerer formula means it can be difficult to get the color to show prominently on medium skin tones.
Deep Skin
For deeper skin tones, many users express disappointment with the color payoff. Despite the “Deep Rose” name, the pigmentation isn’t concentrated enough to show up well on darker skin without significant building up, which can be frustrating and time-consuming.
Several reviewers with deeper skin tones specifically mentioned they couldn’t get the color to show up at all, suggesting this may not be the best option for those with dark skin looking for an efficient, impactful blush.
Value and Price Point
At a typical price point of $5-8, the Maybelline Fit Me! Blush represents good value for the price, especially when compared to high-end blushes that can cost 4-5 times as much. The product lasts for months of regular use despite its seemingly small quantity (0.16 ounce).
Many users specifically mentioned buying this blush repeatedly over several years, indicating good long-term value. The affordable price point makes it accessible for makeup beginners or those on a budget.
Comparison to Similar Products
Vs. Other Drugstore Blushes
Compared to other products in the same price range (like Covergirl, Wet n Wild, or L’Oreal blushes), the Maybelline Fit Me! line offers comparable quality with perhaps better blendability than most. The color selection is considered more sophisticated and natural-looking than some other drugstore options.
Vs. High-End Blushes
While it doesn’t quite match the pigmentation, complexity of finish, or longevity of high-end blushes from brands like NARS or Benefit, many users find it provides about 80% of the performance at 20% of the price, making it an excellent value alternative.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Natural-looking, buildable color
- Excellent blendability
- Portable, compact packaging
- Great value for the price
- Works well for everyday use
- Suitable for sensitive skin
- Pairs well with other makeup
- Available through online retailers when stores don’t carry it
Cons:
- Limited pigmentation for deeper skin tones
- Included brush is small and stiff
- Can be hard-pressed in the pan, making product pickup difficult
- May need reapplication for all-day wear
- Some reviewers mentioned the color has been discontinued in physical stores
- Some users received products with missing brushes or damaged packaging when ordering online
Special Considerations
Reported Discontinuation
Several long-time users mentioned that this particular shade (Deep Rose) has become harder to find in physical stores, with some noting that Maybelline may have discontinued or limited its availability. This makes online purchasing a necessary alternative for loyal users.
Color Expectations
Some users mentioned that the actual color appears lighter than shown in product images, which is worth noting if you’re ordering online without seeing the product in person first.
Best For
This blush would be ideal for:
- Those with fair to light skin seeking a natural-looking blush
- Makeup beginners who prefer buildable, mistake-proof products
- People who prioritize blendability over intense pigmentation
- Those seeking an affordable everyday blush option
- Anyone who prefers a subtle rather than statement blush look
Less Ideal For
This may not be the best choice for:
- Those with deeper skin tones seeking impactful color
- Users looking for highly pigmented, one-swipe application
- Those who need extremely long-wearing formulas without touch-ups
- People who prefer cream or liquid blush formats
Application Recommendations
For optimal results with the Maybelline Fit Me! Blush in Deep Rose:
- Use the right tools: Skip the included brush and use a fuller, fluffier blush brush for better product pickup and diffusion.
- Prep the surface: If you’re having trouble picking up product, gently scratching the surface with your fingernail or brush can help loosen the product in the pan.
- Building technique: For deeper skin tones or more impact, apply in layers, allowing each layer to blend before adding more.
- Placement: Apply to the apples of cheeks and blend upward toward the temples for the most natural, lifting effect.
- Pairing suggestions: This shade pairs beautifully with neutral eye looks and rose or mauve lip colors for a cohesive look.
Final Verdict
The Maybelline New York Fit Me! Blush in Deep Rose earns a solid 3.5/5 stars. It delivers excellent value, good everyday wearability, and remarkable blendability at an affordable price point. Its greatest strengths lie in its natural-looking finish and user-friendly application that’s forgiving for all skill levels.
However, its limited pigmentation makes it less suitable for deeper skin tones, and the included brush leaves much to be desired. The potential discontinued status in physical stores also presents an accessibility concern for loyal users.
For those with fair to light skin seeking an affordable, natural-looking blush for everyday wear, this remains an excellent choice that performs well above its price point. Those with deeper skin tones or who prefer more impactful color payoff might want to explore other options within Maybelline’s line or from other brands with more pigmented formulations.
The Bottom Line
Maybelline’s Fit Me! Blush in Deep Rose excels as an everyday, foolproof blush option for lighter skin tones at a budget-friendly price point. Its natural finish, blendability, and subtle color make it perfect for makeup minimalists and beginners alike, though those seeking drama or with deeper skin tones may find it underwhelming.
This review is based on analysis of customer feedback and professional beauty expertise. Individual experiences may vary depending on skin type, application technique, and personal preferences.
Buy on Amazon: Here
