Hey beauty lovers! Today I’m spilling ALL THE DETAILS on the Maybelline New York Fit Me! Concealer in Fair [10]. I’ve been using this product for months now, and I have THOUGHTS. If you’re considering adding this budget-friendly concealer to your makeup bag, you need to read this first!
First Impressions
When I first got my hands on this concealer, I was honestly a bit skeptical. The price point is so affordable that I wondered if it could really deliver. The packaging is simple – nothing fancy here – just a standard tube with a doe-foot applicator. But hey, it’s what’s inside that counts, right?!
The shade Fair [10] is SUPER light – and that’s actually amazing news for my fellow pale-skinned people who struggle to find concealers that don’t make them look orange! Several reviewers with very fair skin mentioned being thrilled to finally find a concealer light enough for their complexion.
Application Experience
Here’s what REALLY surprised me – this concealer applies like a dream! Just one small dot of product gives impressive coverage. The texture is creamy without being too thick or too runny – it hits that perfect middle ground.
The doe-foot applicator makes it easy to apply precisely where you need it. I typically dot it under my eyes, around my nose, and on any blemishes before blending out with either my fingertips or a damp beauty sponge.
What I love most is how it MELTS into the skin rather than sitting on top. There’s nothing worse than concealer that looks cakey or obvious, and this one absolutely doesn’t do that!
Coverage & Performance
Let’s talk about what this concealer actually DOES:
- Dark circles? It definitely helps brighten the under-eye area, though if you have very severe dark circles, you might need to layer it or use a color corrector underneath.
- Blemishes? It covers them nicely without looking thick or obvious on the skin.
- Redness? It neutralizes it well!
The finish is natural – not too matte and not too dewy. It gives a subtle brightening effect that looks like your skin but better. One reviewer called it “luminous” which is a perfect description!
The staying power is actually impressive for a drugstore product. It lasts through most of my day without creasing badly, though I do find setting it lightly with powder helps extend the wear time even more.
What Makes It Stand Out
What REALLY sets this concealer apart from others I’ve tried (even high-end ones!):
- It doesn’t make the under-eye area look creepy or emphasize fine lines (a HUGE win for anyone over 25!)
- The coverage is buildable without ever looking cakey
- It truly blends seamlessly into the skin
- The fair shade is ACTUALLY fair enough for very pale skin tones
- The price is INCREDIBLE for the quality you get
The Downsides
Okay, I’m all about honesty here, so let’s talk about the not-so-great stuff:
The biggest issue seems to be with ordering online – several people mentioned ordering what was advertised as a 2-pack but only receiving 1 tube. That’s super frustrating! If you’re expecting the 2-pack deal, maybe double-check with the seller before ordering.
The shade range, while good for fair skin, isn’t as extensive as some other brands. If you have a deeper skin tone, you might struggle to find your perfect match.
And while the coverage is good, if you have severe discoloration or very dark circles, you might find it’s not quite enough on its own.
Value for Money
This is where the Maybelline Fit Me! Concealer REALLY shines! For the price, the performance is honestly incredible. One tube lasts me about 3-4 months with regular use, making it an absolute STEAL.
Even makeup artists and beauty influencers recommend this product – one reviewer mentioned that Marlena (aka Makeup Geek) specifically recommends this as part of a foundation routine. When the pros are suggesting a drugstore product, you know it’s good!
Who Should Buy This?
This concealer is PERFECT for:
- Anyone on a budget who doesn’t want to compromise on quality
- People with fair skin who struggle to find shades light enough
- Those who prefer a natural, skin-like finish
- Anyone who hates cakey, obvious-looking concealer
- Makeup beginners (it’s so easy to use!)
- People with slightly dry or normal under-eyes (it’s not overly drying)
If you’re 14 or 40, this concealer works amazingly well! One of the reviewers mentioned being only 14 years old and loving this product, while others seemed to be more mature users who appreciated how it doesn’t emphasize fine lines.
Final Thoughts
I’m now on my third tube of this concealer, and I don’t see myself switching any time soon! Despite trying various high-end concealers, I keep coming back to this affordable gem.
The Maybelline New York Fit Me! Concealer in Fair [10] proves that you don’t need to spend a fortune to get quality makeup. It performs like products triple its price while maintaining a skin-like finish that looks natural in all lighting.
If you’re looking for an affordable, effective concealer that blends beautifully and brightens without creasing, THIS IS IT! Just be careful when ordering online to ensure you’re getting exactly what you paid for.
Have you tried this concealer? What did you think? I’d love to hear your experiences in the comments below!
Rating: 4.5/5 stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐✨
(Half a star off just for the online ordering confusion and somewhat limited shade range, but the product itself is practically perfect!)
Quick Pros & Cons
PROS:
- Affordable price point
- Blends seamlessly
- Natural, brightening finish
- Doesn’t emphasize fine lines
- Great for fair skin tones
- No scent
- Doesn’t look cakey
- Lasts well throughout the day
CONS:
- Some issues with receiving the 2-pack as advertised
- Limited shade range compared to some brands
- May not be enough coverage for severe discoloration
Application Tips
Want to get the MOST out of this concealer? Here are my top tips:
- Less is more! Start with a tiny amount and build up if needed.
- Let it warm up on your skin for about 30 seconds before blending.
- Set lightly with powder if you tend to get oily or want longer wear.
- For extra brightening, choose a shade slightly lighter than your skin tone.
- Apply in a triangle shape under eyes rather than just on dark circles for the most natural-looking brightening effect.
I hope this review helps you decide if the Maybelline Fit Me! Concealer is right for you. At this price point, it’s definitely worth giving it a shot!
Update After 6 Months of Use
I’ve now been using this concealer consistently for about 6 months, and I’m still loving it! The tube lasts surprisingly long, and the formula hasn’t dried out or changed texture over time. For reference, I use it about 5 days a week, and I’m only now starting to run low on my current tube.
One thing I’ve discovered is that it layers beautifully with other products. I sometimes use it over a color corrector for my worst dark circle days, and it doesn’t pill or look heavy.
If you’ve been on the fence about trying this concealer, just DO IT! Your wallet will thank you, and I bet your skin will too!
Buy on Amazon: Here
