Hey beauty lovers! I’ve been testing the Maybelline New York Snapscara Washable Mascara Kit (Pitch Black, Pack of 2) for a few weeks now, and I’m FINALLY ready to spill all the details! As someone who’s tried practically every mascara on the market, I’ve got some thoughts…
- Price Point: Super affordable (especially for a 2-pack!)
- Shade: Pitch Black (deep, true black)
- Formula: Lightweight, wax-free
- Main Claims: Easy application, natural-looking results, and supposedly “off in a snap” removal
- My Bottom Line: A great everyday mascara for natural looks, but the “snaps off” claim is a bit exaggerated
Application Experience
Let me start with how this applies – it’s ACTUALLY really smooth! The brush isn’t too thick, which makes it super easy to coat every single lash without making a mess. The consistency is on the thinner side compared to those super thick, goopy mascaras out there.
First coat goes on lightweight and builds up nicely. I noticed almost zero clumping (and if you’ve used mascara for any length of time, you KNOW how rare that is!). The formula doesn’t feel heavy on my lashes at all – I can barely feel I’m wearing it.
If you’re looking for drama from one coat though? This isn’t it. Snapscara definitely gives more of a “your lashes but better” vibe on the first application. But here’s the good news – it layers really well! Several people mentioned they could build it up for more dramatic looks.
The Results
What you’ll get with Snapscara is LENGTH and DEFINITION. This mascara really excels at separating each lash and extending them. It’s perfect for daytime looks when you want to look put-together but not over-the-top.
One reviewer hit the nail on the head when they said it “goes on lightweight and natural-looking, elongates and separates lashes.” That’s EXACTLY what this does!
What it’s NOT great at: creating massive volume or that false-lash effect. If you’re looking for super thick, dramatic lashes, you might be disappointed with this one.
Staying Power
This is where Snapscara really impressed me! Despite its lightweight formula, this stuff STAYS PUT. Multiple reviewers mentioned it lasted all day without:
- Flaking
- Smudging
- Running
- Fallout
Even with “heavily moisturized face and eyelids” (as one user mentioned), it didn’t budge. And for contact lens wearers – this is a big deal! Though I should note one reviewer who wears contacts did mention flaking issues, so your experience might vary.
I wore this through long workdays and even a workout (I know, I should remove makeup before exercising, but TESTING!) and it held up surprisingly well.
The Big Claim: Easy Removal
OK, here’s where Maybelline’s marketing gets a little ahead of reality. They claim this mascara comes “off in a snap” – and based on user feedback, that’s not entirely true.
Is it EASIER to remove than waterproof formulas? Absolutely! Is it “off in a snap”? Not quite.
The consensus seems to be:
- It does come off with just warm water and facial cleanser (no need for special makeup remover)
- It requires a bit more than just a “snap” – some gentle rubbing is needed
- One reviewer suggested “warm water to melt the product down, as opposed to a makeup remover that works by dissolving oils”
On the plus side, this gentler removal process means less lash breakage! One user specifically mentioned loving “that it doesn’t cause my eyelashes to break if I forget to wash it off before bed.”
Value Factor
Getting TWO tubes of this mascara for the price is honestly a steal. Multiple reviewers mentioned being impressed with the value, with one calling it “such a great value” and another noting it’s “much less expensive than my usual brand.”
For college students or anyone on a budget, this is a great option that doesn’t feel like you’re compromising quality for price.
The Not-So-Great Stuff
In the interest of keeping it 100% real with you, I should mention some negatives from the reviews:
- One user found it “watery going on” and disliked how it made lashes “hard as a rock”
- A few people experienced some flaking (though they were definitely in the minority)
- One person mentioned it “burns my eyes when I took it off” (though this could be from rubbing too hard)
- A handful of users found it lacking in pigmentation, with one saying “it took so many applications to make it look like I had any eyelashes”
- One review simply stated “I returned this” without elaboration
Who This Mascara is PERFECT For
Based on all the feedback, Snapscara is ideal if you:
- Prefer a natural, defined lash look over dramatic volume
- Want something that applies easily without clumping
- Need mascara that lasts all day without smudging
- Prefer simple removal with just water and face wash
- Are looking for an affordable everyday option
Who Should Skip It
You might want to pass if you:
- Crave dramatic, voluminous, false-lash effects
- Need extra pigmentation for sparse lashes
- Have sensitive eyes (due to the one report of burning)
- Want instant removal without any effort
Final Thoughts
The Maybelline New York Snapscara Washable Mascara Kit delivers exactly what it promises in most areas – a lightweight, natural-looking mascara that defines and lengthens without clumping or smudging. While the “snaps off” claim is a bit exaggerated, it IS easier to remove than many other long-wearing formulas.
For everyday wear, especially if you prefer a more natural look, this is a SOLID choice at an amazing price point. The 2-pack makes it even more economical – keep one in your makeup bag and one in your gym bag!
Would I recommend it? For most people, absolutely YES! Just go in with realistic expectations about the level of drama and the removal process, and I think you’ll be pleasantly surprised by this affordable little gem.
What’s your experience with Snapscara? Drop a comment below – I’d love to hear if it worked for you as well as it did for most reviewers!
Buy on Amazon: Here
