In the diverse and often overwhelming world of mascaras, finding the right balance between ease of use, color intensity, and performance can be tricky. Maybelline New York’s Snapscara Washable Mascara in “Black Cherry” aims to deliver easy application and unique color for those looking beyond classic black. But does it live up to its claims? I tested it thoroughly to answer this question for you.
First Impressions and Packaging
When I first received the Maybelline Snapscara, the product packaging caught my eye immediately. The squared-off tube design is not only practical—avoiding the annoying roll-off from vanity tops—but also sleek and modern. However, my initial excitement dimmed upon opening it. The mascara formula appeared notably thick and somewhat dry, which raised concerns about freshness or shelf-life.
Several users have reported issues of the mascara arriving dried out and unusable, with one even noting mold growth in the tube—something that’s unacceptable for a cosmetic product. It seems this could be related to improper storage or older batches being sold online, emphasizing the need to purchase from reputable sources.
Color Expectations vs. Reality
The primary selling point for many, including myself, was the intriguing “Black Cherry” shade. The packaging and promotional photos suggest a dark, sophisticated burgundy tint ideal for enhancing green or hazel eyes. Unfortunately, reality fell short of these expectations. Most users, myself included, found the mascara to look predominantly black once applied, with virtually no noticeable reddish or cherry undertones.
Some customers did observe a subtle difference compared to traditional black mascaras—a less harsh, warmer black—but the promised burgundy pop was missing. Users with lighter or blond eyelashes noticed slightly more color payoff, while darker-lashed users found almost no noticeable cherry hue.
Formula and Application Experience
Despite initial formula concerns, applying the mascara provided a mixed yet intriguing experience. The formula was smooth and creamy for some, yet disappointingly dry and flaky for others. Those who found the formula agreeable praised it for being clump-free, buildable, and easy to apply, particularly appreciating how it defined lashes subtly without overly dramatic volume or thickness.
However, many users experienced flaking shortly after application, with tiny mascara specks appearing under the eyes within an hour or two. This was particularly problematic for those with sensitive eyes or contact lenses. Application seemed most successful when combined with a mascara primer, significantly reducing flakiness.
The Brush: A Saving Grace?
The Snapscara brush emerged as one of the standout features of the product, garnering near-universal praise. Its curved, fluffy design effectively separated lashes, preventing clumping and creating a natural, lengthened appearance. Users particularly loved the ease of applying mascara to the corners and tips of lashes due to the wand’s shape.
However, the brush design wasn’t without critique. Some found the curve awkward to maneuver, especially on the non-dominant eye. The bristle spacing was also noted as too wide by some users, who preferred denser brushes for greater lash volume.
Longevity and Wear
The mascara’s wearability offered an interesting trade-off. Snapscara’s washable formula promises easy removal with warm water, and it delivered exceptionally on this promise. Users appreciated how effortlessly the mascara came off without leaving residues or raccoon eyes—a notable advantage for those who hate mascara removal struggles.
However, this ease of removal translated into poor staying power. The mascara visibly faded or thinned significantly throughout the day, with lashes looking noticeably less defined after 8-12 hours. Humid climates, tears, sweat, or rain quickly led to smudging or complete removal. If long-lasting, waterproof wear is essential, Snapscara may disappoint.
Suitability for Eye Colors and Skin Types
Although the color disappointed many, there was a surprising consensus that the subtle warmth of “Black Cherry” still managed to slightly enhance hazel, green, or lighter eye colors. Users with sensitive eyes praised the gentle formula for causing minimal to no irritation. Those who usually struggle with mascara allergies or sensitivities reported a largely positive experience with this product.
However, contact lens wearers should exercise caution due to the formula’s tendency to flake, risking particles in the eyes.
Pricing and Value for Money
Priced at around $5, the Snapscara mascara undeniably sits at an appealing price point. Most users felt the product offered reasonable value, particularly highlighting the quality brush and ease of removal. For many, even if the formula wasn’t perfect, the cost made it a low-risk experiment.
Yet, despite the appealing price, numerous buyers felt deceived due to the color discrepancy and inconsistent product quality (e.g., dried out tubes or older batches). The potential hassle of returns, restocking fees, and dealing with unsatisfactory customer service further diminished perceived value for some.
Pros and Cons Overview
Pros:
- Gentle formula suitable for sensitive eyes
- Easy to apply, minimal clumping
- Excellent brush design
- Washes off effortlessly
- Budget-friendly
Cons:
- Color not as advertised (more black than cherry)
- Frequent issues with product dryness or expired tubes
- Significant flaking issues
- Short wear duration, low smudge resistance
- Inconsistent volume and length results
Final Thoughts and Recommendations
Overall, Maybelline New York Snapscara Washable Mascara in “Black Cherry” proves to be a mixed bag. For those seeking a gentle, easy-to-remove mascara with subtle lash enhancement, it can be a valuable addition. Particularly appealing is its affordable price, making it suitable for everyday wear without breaking the bank.
However, if you are specifically drawn to the Black Cherry shade expecting a vivid burgundy or red tint, you will likely be disappointed. Consider this mascara if you prioritize ease of removal and subtle definition over bold color and longevity.
For those curious but wary, purchasing from a reputable retailer is crucial. Given the numerous reports of receiving dry or outdated products, carefully selecting a trusted source could greatly improve your overall satisfaction.
In conclusion, while the Snapscara mascara isn’t revolutionary, it fills a niche for those desiring gentle, natural-looking lashes with fuss-free removal. Maybelline’s innovative brush design and washable formula hint at the potential for greatness, making it a decent choice—if you temper your expectations accordingly.
Buy on Amazon: Here
