As a beauty expert who has tested countless makeup products over the years, I’m excited to share my in-depth review of the Maybelline New York Super Stay Better Skin Powder in Warm Nude (0.32 oz). This pressed powder has developed something of a cult following among makeup enthusiasts, and for good reason. Based on both personal experience and the collective feedback from numerous users, I’ll explore what makes this product special, why it continues to be sought after despite being discontinued in many physical stores, and whether it truly deserves its devoted fan base.
The Maybelline New York Super Stay Better Skin Powder is a versatile pressed powder foundation that promises long-lasting coverage with skin-improving benefits. Marketed as part of Maybelline’s “Super Stay” line, this powder is designed to provide medium to full coverage while maintaining a natural, non-cakey appearance. The compact comes with a convenient applicator sponge and a mirror, making it perfect for on-the-go touch-ups.
Availability Issues
Before diving into the product’s performance, it’s important to address the elephant in the room: availability. A recurring theme in customer feedback is that this product has been discontinued in physical stores, forcing loyal users to seek it out online. This discontinuation has created a significant demand, with many customers reporting they “stock up” when they find it available. The scarcity has led to some quality control issues with online purchases, which I’ll address later in this review.
Formula and Texture
The Super Stay Better Skin Powder features a finely-milled, silky texture that feels lightweight on the skin. The powder is pressed firmly in the compact, which minimizes fallout during application – a common complaint with many pressed powders. This tight pressing also contributes to the product’s longevity, as you don’t waste product with each use.
The formula is designed to be buildable, allowing users to achieve their desired level of coverage without creating a heavy, mask-like appearance. It’s versatile enough to be used alone as a powder foundation or as a setting powder over liquid foundation.
One of the most praised aspects of the formula is its skin-compatibility. Multiple users with sensitive, acne-prone skin report that this powder doesn’t cause breakouts, which is remarkable considering that “EVERY makeup” causes breakouts for some of these users. This suggests that the formula is non-comedogenic and suitable for a wide range of skin types.
Coverage and Finish
The coverage of the Super Stay Better Skin Powder is described as medium to full, depending on the application method. When applied with the included sponge applicator, it provides more coverage, making it suitable as a standalone foundation. When applied with a fluffy brush, it offers a lighter finish that works well for setting makeup or for a more natural look.
The finish is consistently described as “natural,” “flawless,” and “smooth.” Users appreciate that it doesn’t look like they’re wearing heavy makeup, even when used to achieve full coverage. The powder manages to cover imperfections, sun spots, and blemishes effectively without creating a cakey appearance, which is a delicate balance that many powder foundations fail to achieve.
Several users mentioned that the powder transforms their makeup from “obviously has makeup” to a “more smooth and natural look,” suggesting that it has excellent blending properties that help create a seamless finish.
Longevity and Oil Control
For those with oily skin, this powder is particularly beneficial. Multiple reviews mention its ability to “keep oil at bay” and provide long-lasting coverage throughout the day. While some noted slight fading by the end of the day, they didn’t consider this a significant issue since it maintained a decent appearance until they returned home.
The oil-controlling properties don’t come at the expense of comfort. Unlike many mattifying powders that can feel drying or tight on the skin, the Super Stay Better Skin Powder is described as feeling like “wearing nothing” or “lightweight,” indicating that it controls oil without stripping the skin’s moisture.
Application and Versatility
A standout feature of this powder is its versatility in application methods. While many pressed powders perform poorly when applied with the included sponge applicator, numerous users reported that this powder applies beautifully regardless of whether they use the sponge or a brush.
For those who prefer a medium coverage, applying the powder alone with either the sponge or a dense brush works well. For fuller coverage, users recommend layering it over foundation, which creates a “flawless non cakey finish.” For those seeking a more natural look, applying it with a “very big, fluffy brush” provides lighter coverage while still effectively setting makeup.
This versatility makes the product suitable for various makeup routines and preferences, from minimal everyday looks to more polished, full-coverage applications.
Shade Range and Color Match
The shade “Warm Nude” appears to work well for many users with light to medium skin tones with warm undertones. One user specifically mentioned that “No. 30 is a good color,” suggesting this might be an alternative name or number for the shade.
While this review focuses on the Warm Nude shade, it’s worth noting that several users mentioned ordering multiple compacts, indicating a loyalty to specific shades that work well for their skin tones.
Skin Benefits and Comfort
True to its name, the “Better Skin” aspect of this powder is reflected in user experiences. Multiple reviews mention that the powder doesn’t irritate sensitive skin, doesn’t cause breakouts, and feels comfortable throughout the day. For those with acne-prone skin, finding a foundation that provides good coverage without exacerbating skin issues is particularly valuable.
The powder is also praised for its ability to reduce the appearance of pores, which contributes to the “flawless” finish that many users describe. This pore-minimizing effect is typically associated with higher-end foundations, making this drugstore option particularly impressive.
Value and Longevity of Product
At 0.32 oz, the compact contains a standard amount of product for a pressed powder. Users report that it “lasts a long time,” suggesting good value for the price point. The fact that many customers order multiple compacts at once to “stock up” indicates that the product doesn’t expire quickly and maintains its quality over time.
Quality Control Issues with Online Purchases
A concerning trend in the reviews is the mention of quality control issues when purchasing online. Several customers reported receiving products that had “already been opened,” lacked tamper-proof stickers, or showed signs of being used (swipe marks in the product, dirty sponges). In one case, a customer ordered four compacts and “one came cracked.”
These issues suggest that some online retailers may be reselling returned items or that the packaging is insufficient to protect the product during shipping. Potential buyers should carefully inspect their purchases upon arrival and be prepared to return items that show signs of tampering or damage.
Comparison to Alternatives
One of the strongest endorsements for this product comes from long-term users who have tried alternatives but returned to the Super Stay Better Skin Powder. Multiple reviewers mentioned using this product “for years” or “since I was 16 years old,” and despite trying “many others,” they found that “none of them compare to this.”
This loyalty in the face of discontinuation speaks volumes about the product’s unique qualities. Users are willing to seek it out online rather than switch to more readily available alternatives, suggesting that it fills a niche in the market that other products don’t adequately address.
Potential Changes in Formula
One user noted that the product they received “definitely not the same product from the drugstore” and that “the powder felt very different and it didn’t have the coverage that the original one has.” This raises questions about whether Maybelline may have reformulated the product before discontinuing it in stores, or whether some online listings might be selling counterfeit versions.
This discrepancy is worth noting for long-time users who are considering purchasing the product online. While most reviewers seemed satisfied with their online purchases, the possibility of formula changes or counterfeit products is a consideration.
Who Should Try This Product
Based on the collective feedback, this powder is particularly well-suited for:
- Those with oily or combination skin who need oil control without a heavy feel
- People with sensitive or acne-prone skin who struggle to find foundations that don’t cause breakouts
- Users who prefer a buildable coverage that can be adapted for different occasions
- Those who value a natural, skin-like finish rather than a matte or powdery appearance
- Makeup wearers who need long-lasting coverage without frequent touch-ups
Who Might Want to Skip This Product
This powder might not be ideal for:
- Those with very dry skin, as some oil-controlling properties might emphasize dry patches
- Users who need very full coverage for significant discoloration, as it’s primarily a medium-coverage product
- People who prefer a dewy finish, as this powder has more of a natural to matte finish
The Discontinuation Dilemma
The apparent discontinuation of this product in physical stores presents both a challenge and an opportunity. For loyal users, it means potentially stockpiling the product or regularly searching online for reliable sellers. For Maybelline, the strong continued demand suggests that they might benefit from bringing the product back to store shelves.
The discontinuation also raises questions about Maybelline’s product strategy. With so many devoted users expressing disappointment about the product being discontinued, it’s surprising that the company would remove such a seemingly successful item from their lineup. This could indicate shifting market trends or reformulation plans for their powder foundation offerings.
Final Verdict
The Maybelline New York Super Stay Better Skin Powder in Warm Nude has earned its cult status through consistent performance, skin-friendly formula, and versatile application options. Despite availability challenges, users continue to seek it out, which speaks to its unique position in the pressed powder market.
For those considering trying this product, the potential quality control issues with online purchases are a consideration, but the risk seems worth it for many users who have developed a strong loyalty to this specific powder. New users should inspect their purchases carefully and be prepared to return items that show signs of tampering.
With its combination of coverage, comfort, and skin benefits, this powder represents excellent value in the drugstore beauty category. Whether used alone for medium coverage or paired with foundation for a flawless finish, it delivers reliable results that have kept users coming back for years.
The most compelling endorsement comes from those who have tried alternatives and returned to this product: in a market saturated with options, the Super Stay Better Skin Powder continues to stand out as a superior choice for those who have discovered its benefits.
Recommendations for Maybelline
If representatives from Maybelline happen to read this review, here’s a strong recommendation: consider bringing this product back to store shelves. The passionate user base and continued online demand suggest that there’s still a significant market for this powder foundation. At the very least, ensuring consistent quality control for online purchases would help maintain the product’s reputation and customer satisfaction.
In the meantime, for those who have found their perfect match in the Super Stay Better Skin Powder, stocking up when you find a reliable source seems to be the consensus approach. And for those who haven’t tried it yet but are intrigued by its reputation, it might be worth seeking out this increasingly elusive product to experience its benefits firsthand.
Rating: 4.5/5 Stars
Pros:
- Excellent coverage without cakiness
- Doesn’t cause breakouts on sensitive skin
- Versatile application methods
- Long-lasting with good oil control
- Natural, flawless finish
Cons:
- Discontinued in many physical stores
- Some quality control issues with online purchases
- Possible formula inconsistencies
- Limited shade availability
This powder foundation remains a standout product in the drugstore category, earning its devoted following through years of reliable performance. If you can find it from a reputable seller, it’s well worth adding to your makeup collection.
Buy on Amazon: Here
