Hey everyone! I finally got my hands on the Maybelline New York Super Stay Up to 24HR Skin Tint, and after trying it for a while, I just HAD to share my thoughts with you all! This review is based on my personal experience and what others are saying about it.
First Impressions
When I first received the product (shade 355), I was immediately drawn to the sleek packaging. It comes with a dropper applicator which, while not perfect (more on that later), does give you some control over how much product you use. The formula has a nice consistency – not too thick but not watery either.
Application & Coverage
Let me be SUPER clear about the coverage – it’s exactly as advertised: light-to-medium. If you’re expecting full coverage that will hide everything, this isn’t it! But that’s actually what I love about it. It gives your skin this beautiful, natural radiance while evening out your skin tone.
The product blends incredibly well. You can use your fingers, a beauty sponge, or a brush – all work great. I personally prefer using a damp beauty sponge for that airbrushed finish. It really does feel weightless on the skin, which is AMAZING for daily wear!
Several reviewers mentioned how natural it looks, with one saying it “looks like I’m not even wearing makeup!” I totally agree – it gives you that “your skin but better” look.
Longevity
Does it really last 24 hours? Well, I haven’t worn it for a full 24 hours (who does?), but I can confirm it holds up remarkably well throughout a normal day. It resists sweat pretty well, which is perfect as we head into warmer weather.
One reviewer mentioned it’s “long lasting and definitely adds a glow.” I found it maintains its radiance without getting oily, even on my combination skin. That’s pretty impressive!
Formula & Feel
The Vitamin C infusion isn’t just marketing hype – my skin actually does look brighter with continued use. It feels hydrating without being greasy. For those with dry or mature skin, several reviewers mentioned it works well for them: “Works well with my dry mature skin. Feels soft and easy to use.”
It’s also worth noting that it’s vegan, dermatologically tested, and suitable for sensitive skin. I haven’t experienced any irritation or breakouts while using it.
Shade Range
Finding the right shade can be tricky (isn’t it always?). The product comes in 18 shades, which is decent but not extensive. A few reviewers mentioned getting shades that were darker than expected: “It is a little darker than I anticipated” and “Unfortunately I ordered too darker color.”
If you’re between shades, I’d recommend going slightly lighter as it seems to oxidize a bit. Shade 355 is perfect for light-medium skin with warm undertones, and will be especially great for summer as one reviewer mentioned.
Some users noted a slight orange undertone. One clever reviewer suggested: “The product is amazing only thing is that it appears with a slight orange undertone. Just add a little blue correcter to it to neutralize it.” Great tip!
The Dropper Issue
OK, let’s talk about the elephant in the room – the dropper. Multiple reviewers (including myself) have found it problematic. One reviewer warned: “You can’t use the dropper to put on your face or it will fall out all over the place.” Another mentioned: “This product is quite good but the only problem is that it can get very messy if not careful.”
My tip: Apply it to the back of your hand first or directly onto your beauty sponge rather than your face. This prevents those dreaded makeup accidents! One reviewer learned this the hard way: “It ruined my dress.” Yikes!
Value for Money
For a drugstore product, this delivers results comparable to high-end alternatives. One enthusiastic reviewer claimed: “I’ve purchased expensive and cheap, truly this is the best!” I wouldn’t go that far, but it definitely punches above its weight class in terms of quality.
Who Should Buy This?
This skin tint is PERFECT for:
- People who prefer natural-looking makeup
- Those with normal to dry skin
- Anyone looking for everyday, low-maintenance makeup
- People who want skincare benefits in their foundation (hello, Vitamin C!)
You might want to skip this if:
- You need full coverage
- You have extremely oily skin
- You’re clumsy with droppers (kidding… sort of)
Final Thoughts
The Maybelline Super Stay Skin Tint delivers on most of its promises. It provides a beautiful radiant finish, comfortable wear, and decent staying power. The Vitamin C is a nice bonus that actually seems to make a difference with continued use.
Yes, the packaging could be improved (seriously, Maybelline, rethink that dropper!), and shade matching can be tricky, but overall, it’s a solid product that deserves a spot in your makeup collection.
As one reviewer perfectly summed it up: “Light weight buildable medium coverage that has a nice glow.” That’s really what this product is all about!
Have you tried this skin tint yet? I’d love to hear your thoughts if you have! And if you’re on the fence, I’d say it’s definitely worth giving a shot. For the price point, it’s hard to be disappointed with the results!
Happy makeup-ing! 😊
Buy on Amazon: Here
