So I’ve been using Maybelline’s Line Stiletto eyeliner Blackest Black for YEARS now, and I’m finally sitting down to share all my thoughts about it with you guys. If you’re looking for a good drugstore liquid liner that won’t break the bank but still delivers, keep reading!
First Impressions & Packaging
The Line Stiletto comes in a sleek black container that’s super compact – perfect for throwing in your makeup bag without taking up much space. The applicator handle is the PERFECT length (not too long like some liners where you can’t keep a steady hand). It has a felt tip applicator rather than a brush, which makes it pretty beginner-friendly.
One thing to note: the tip isn’t ultra-fine and pointy – it’s more of a tapered felt tip. This works for most looks but might be challenging if you’re trying to create super intricate designs.
Application Experience
This liner is REALLY easy to use! The felt tip gives you good control whether you want a thin line or something thicker and more dramatic. It glides on pretty smoothly without skipping, which is a huge plus. Sometimes you might need to dip back into the tube a few times while applying, especially if you’re going for a bolder look.
The formula is pretty wet when first applied, but it dries down quickly – usually within seconds. Just don’t blink too quickly after application or you might get a little transfer.
I love that I can build it up from a thin line to something thicker if I want to change my look. For beginners, this is a great starter liquid liner since it’s forgiving and easy to control.
Color Payoff
The “Blackest Black” shade is ACTUALLY black! 🙌 It’s not one of those liners that looks gray or faded when applied. The color is rich and delivers good pigmentation, though sometimes you might need to go over the line twice to get it fully opaque if the applicator is running low on product.
The finish has a slight sheen to it – not completely matte but not super glossy either. Some people have mentioned putting black eyeshadow over it to reduce the slight glare, but I personally don’t find that necessary.
Staying Power
This is where opinions really vary depending on your skin type and environment:
If you have DRY skin: This liner is your best friend! It tends to stay put all day without smudging or transferring.
If you have OILY lids: You might struggle a bit more. Some users with oily skin report that it can blur or fade throughout the day.
In normal conditions, I get about 6-8 hours of wear before noticing any fading. It’s definitely not completely waterproof, but it has decent staying power for the price. Living in a hot or humid climate will definitely challenge its longevity – some Florida users mentioned needing to touch up after several hours.
One thing to note – it can flake a bit if you rub your eyes or if you’ve been wearing it for a really long time. I’ve noticed little black flecks sometimes if I’ve had it on for 10+ hours.
Removal
Honestly, one of the BEST things about this liner is how easy it is to remove! You don’t need special makeup remover – just a bit of water and gentle pressure will take most of it off. This makes it perfect for:
- Fixing mistakes while applying (just use a dry Q-tip!)
- Removing at the end of the day without tugging at your eyes
- Creating precise looks with the ability to clean up edges
If you’re someone who struggles with removing stubborn makeup, you’ll appreciate this feature!
Longevity (of the product itself)
With daily use, one tube typically lasts about 3-4 months before drying up, which is pretty good value! Some reviewers mentioned getting 4+ months with almost daily use. Just make sure to close it tightly after each use to prevent it from drying out.
One complaint I’ve seen repeatedly is that some people feel like there’s less product in newer bottles compared to older versions of this liner. Hard to verify, but worth mentioning.
Price Point
At around $6-8 depending where you buy it, this is DEFINITELY on the affordable end of liquid liners. Compared to high-end options like Stila that cost $22+, it’s a steal! The quality-to-price ratio is excellent.
Pros & Cons
Pros:
- Easy to apply with good control
- Actually BLACK (great pigmentation)
- Affordable price point
- Lasts a decent amount of time on most skin types
- Quick drying formula
- Easy to remove when you want to
- Good sized applicator for precise lines
- Versatile for thick or thin lines
Cons:
- Not waterproof (will smudge if you cry or swim)
- Can flake after extended wear
- May not last all day on oily lids
- Not the most precise tip for extremely detailed work
- Formula seems to have changed over years according to some longtime users
- Can be a bit watery at times
Who Should Buy This?
This liner is PERFECT for:
- Beginners just learning liquid liner
- People with dry to normal skin
- Those who want an affordable everyday liner
- People who prefer easy removal
- Anyone who needs versatility in line thickness
Maybe skip it if:
- You have super oily lids
- You need something 100% waterproof
- You want an ultra-fine precision tip
- You need 12+ hour smudge-proof wear
Final Thoughts
After trying everything from high-end department store brands to other drugstore options, I keep coming back to Maybelline Line Stiletto. It’s reliable, easy to use, and doesn’t break the bank. Is it the absolute BEST liquid liner in the world? No – but it’s definitely one of the best values!
For everyday wear, quick application, and a clean look, this has become my go-to. The fact that I can create a perfect wing in seconds without struggling makes it a winner in my book. And at this price point, I don’t feel guilty replacing it regularly.
If you’re on the fence, I’d say give it a shot! Worst case scenario, you’re only out a few dollars, but I bet you’ll be pleasantly surprised by this little drugstore gem. Just remember to shake it before use to keep the formula consistent.
Would I repurchase? ABSOLUTELY – and I have, multiple times! That’s probably the best endorsement I can give any beauty product.
Let me know if you try it – I’d love to hear your experience with it too!
Buy on Amazon: Here
