Hey there, lip balm lovers! Today I’m diving DEEP into one of the most iconic drugstore lip products of all time – the Maybelline New York Baby Lips Moisturizing Lip Balm 3-pack. If you’ve been around the beauty block, you’ve definitely spotted these colorful tubes at some point. But are they still worth the hype in 2025? Let’s find out!
First Impressions: The Packaging That Started a Trend
Let’s start with what catches your eye first – those unmistakable tubes! The Maybelline Baby Lips 3-pack comes with three different colored tubes that are:
- Super portable (perfect purse size)
- Retro-cute packaging that stands out
- Sturdy enough to survive being tossed around in bags
I’ve noticed some people mentioning the tubes might be slightly smaller than they used to be, but honestly, they still last FOREVER even with daily use. One reviewer mentioned having them “stashed all over the house” – and I totally get that strategy!
What’s In The Pack: The Color Lineup
The standard 3-pack typically includes:
- Quenched – The clear one with no tint (great for nighttime moisture)
- Cherry Me – The fan-favorite with a subtle red tint
- Dr. Rescue/Coral Crave – Either the mentholated rescue version or the coral shade
Important note: There seems to be some confusion about the SPF. Some packs are advertised with the blue tube (Quenched) having SPF 20, but MANY reviewers reported receiving packs without any SPF protection. So don’t count on the sun protection unless it’s specifically labeled on your tube!
The Feel: Smooth Operator
The BEST thing about Baby Lips is how it feels going on. Unlike traditional waxy chapsticks that sit heavy on your lips, these:
- Glide on incredibly smoothly
- Feel lightweight (not sticky AT ALL)
- Provide a subtle shine without being too glossy
- Leave a natural-looking finish
As one reviewer put it: “Baby Lips are one of the best purchases I ever made. There is nothing like them! They are a pure joy as they glide along your lips.”
The Moisture Factor: Does It Actually Work?
Let’s get real – the primary job of any lip balm is to moisturize, right? Based on the reviews, Baby Lips delivers decent hydration:
- Contains shea butter, vitamin E, and honey
- Prevents chapping in normal conditions
- Works well in cold weather for many users
- Isn’t as intensely moisturizing as some medicated balms
A few reviewers mentioned that after long-term use, they noticed their lips seemed to need more frequent application. This might be the case with many lip products – your mileage may vary!
The Tint Factor: Makeup Without The Fuss
For those who hate wearing lipstick but still want a little color, Baby Lips hits the sweet spot:
- Cherry Me gives a subtle red tint that enhances natural lip color
- The tint is buildable but never looks like “makeup”
- Perfect for a natural, no-makeup makeup look
- Great for all ages (one reviewer called it “just right for a senior lady”)
Scent & Taste: The Candy Shop Vibes
Baby Lips balms have a distinct scent that most people seem to love:
- Cherry Me smells sweet like candy
- Quenched has a light, fruity scent (one reviewer described it as “lychee”)
- Dr. Rescue has a slightly medicinal, minty smell
The good news? While they smell nice, they don’t have an overwhelming taste that would tempt you to lick it off (which just makes your lips drier in the long run!).
Longevity: How Long Does It Last?
On your lips: You’ll need to reapply every few hours for moisture, especially if you’re eating or drinking. The Cherry tint lasts a bit longer than you might expect from a balm.
In the tube: These little guys last MONTHS even with daily use. Great value for the money!
The Cult Following: Why People Are Obsessed
What’s fascinating about Baby Lips is the intense loyalty it inspires:
- “I have Baby Lips on me literally everyday.”
- “It would be a mistake if they canceled this product! Meanwhile I keep stockpiling it because it’s so good!”
- “I keep one tube in my purse, one in my bathroom cabinet, one in my office.”
People aren’t just buying these because they work – they’re buying them because they’ve become a comfort product. It’s a beauty staple that delivers consistent results.
The Not-So-Great Stuff: Keeping It Real
No product is perfect, so here are the common complaints:
- Inconsistent SPF: Some packs advertise SPF but don’t include it
- Expiration concerns: One reviewer received a pack expiring in just three weeks
- Reapplication needed: Doesn’t last as long on lips as some would like
- Dr. Rescue sensitivity: A few users reported irritation from the mentholated version
- Formula changes: Some longtime users feel the formula isn’t quite what it used to be
Who Should Buy This 3-Pack?
Baby Lips is PERFECT for:
- People who hate heavy lipsticks but want a hint of color
- Anyone looking for a non-sticky, lightweight lip balm
- Those who appreciate versatility (clear for moisture, tinted for color)
- Gift-givers (several reviewers mentioned giving these as gifts)
- People who lose lip balms frequently (having 3 means you can keep them everywhere!)
Creative Uses Beyond Basic Lip Care
Reviewers have found smart ways to maximize their Baby Lips:
- Use over lipstick for added shine and moisture
- Apply under matte lipsticks to prevent drying
- Use the clear one overnight as a lip mask
- Use it to smooth down flyaway hairs in a pinch
Final Verdict: Are Maybelline Baby Lips Worth It in 2025?
YES! These little tubes have stood the test of time for good reason. They deliver on their core promises – smooth application, light moisture, subtle tint, and comfortable wear. While they’re not the most intensely hydrating product for severely chapped lips, they’re perfect for everyday maintenance.
At the current price point (usually around $11 for the 3-pack), they’re still a beauty bargain considering how long they last and how versatile they are.
My personal recommendation? If you’re a first-time buyer, go for it. If you’re a longtime fan wondering if they’re still good – they may have subtle formula changes, but they’re still solid performers that deserve a spot in your lip care collection!
Quick Pros & Cons Summary
PROS:
- Smooth, non-sticky formula
- Subtle, natural-looking tints
- Pleasant scents
- Lightweight feel
- Versatile (can use under/over lipstick)
- Cute packaging
- Good value for money
- Works for all ages
CONS:
- SPF inconsistencies between advertising and actual product
- Need frequent reapplication
- Not intensely hydrating for severely dry lips
- Some sensitivity issues with Dr. Rescue
- Possible formula changes over the years
Have you tried Baby Lips? Which shade is YOUR favorite? Let me know in the comments! ✨👄
Disclaimer: This review is based on consumer experiences and not sponsored by Maybelline.
Buy on Amazon: Here
